Deep dive NATO and Ukraine

Shenzhen summit leaves security guarantees for Ukraine unresolved

After the Shenzhen summit, US envoy Kushner says Russia accepts guarantees like Article 5, just without NATO. Zelensky reports a US proposal to offer NATO membership in exchange for giving up the Donbas. Macron wants the membership question reopened. There are no firm commitments.

  • 455 news items
  • 166 sources
Row of concrete anti-tank obstacles and a barbed wire fence on a snowy field, a watchtower on the horizon
Image AI-generated (AegisSight)

Data from the AegisSight Monitor. Request trial access

  • On 19 November 2026, a trilateral summit between Donald Trump, Xi Jinping and Vladimir Putin took place at the margins of the APEC summit in Shenzhen 512 Toulouse7.com18 France 2468 Telegram: The Kyiv Independent70 Kyiv Post. In several analyses, this is described as the first trilateral meeting of these three heads of state in history 4041 X: @CSIS64 Telegram: Our Wars, Today.
  • The three heads of state adopted a joint peace declaration 1521 Le Figaro51 Sib.fm70 Kyiv Post. According to Kyiv Post and according to a reproduction by the X account @sentdefender, it includes among other things the affirmation that nuclear war cannot be won, a dialogue on nuclear risks, UN reform, plans to increase refined oil production and a warning against encroachments by the International Criminal Court 4250 X: @dpa70 Kyiv Post.
  • In parallel, the Coalition of the Willing met in the Federal Chancellery in Berlin 1150 X: @dpa56 Tagesspiegel. According to Tagesspiegel, Trump joined by telephone from Air Force One and apparently criticised the billions in aid to Kyiv 5667 Telegram: Military Summary.
  • French President Emmanuel Macron called on Ukraine's allies to revisit the question of NATO membership 68 RTE.ie10 Kyiv Post.
  • According to NewsCord and several X commentators, US envoys Jared Kushner and Steve Witkoff stated that Russia agreed to security guarantees 'like Article 5 but not NATO' 735 X: @nicolange_36 X: @CarloMasala1. Trump himself, according to a summary by the Chinese finance channel Caijing Manbao, rejected the question about NATO-like guarantees at a press conference and called discussions about them 'premature' 62.
  • According to an X post by Welt, Volodymyr Zelensky reported a US initiative to offer Ukraine NATO membership in exchange for relinquishing Donbass 37.
  • The background is the Ukrainian attack on the Kerch Bridge on 17 November 2026. According to several sources of claim, Putin announced a considerably more painful response 5861 Telegram: WarGonzo.
  • Chinese and Russian state media present the summit as a landmark event 12 Global Times3 Xinhua (news.cn), whilst Western analyses (GMF, CSIS, Atlantic Council) assess it soberly 4041 X: @CSIS47 X: @gmfus48 X: @AtlanticCouncil and Polish media describe it as a historic meeting without a breakthrough 2629 Radio Zet30 Centrum Europy.

First trilateral meeting of the three heads of state

The summit in Shenzhen is described in several reports and in an assessment by the Center for Strategic and International Studies (CSIS) as the first trilateral meeting of the heads of state of Russia, China and the USA 512 Toulouse7.com18 France 2440 X: @CSIS41 X: @CSIS. According to CSIS information, Trump travelled to Asia from 16 to 19 November 2026, with stops at the ASEAN summit in Manila and the APEC Economic Leaders' Meeting in Shenzhen, where he met with Xi Jinping and Putin 40.

According to CSIS, Trump and Xi met for the third time this year, following meetings in Beijing in May and at the White House in September 41. As early as 14 November, the New York Post had reported, according to a report from the Telegram channel Our Wars, Today, that the three-way summit would be prepared for 19 November and was to address the control of nuclear weapons 64. The British Royal United Services Institute (RUSI) pointed out before the summit that Trump wanted to expand the Ukraine talks into a broader European security agreement, a demand that Moscow had long made and NATO had long rejected 33.

Political scientist Carlo Masala referred in an X post to the analysis that Moscow would attempt to steer the talks between Russia and Ukraine towards a broad US-Russian discussion about world order and European security 38. An article in the Indian magazine Outlook India discussed before the summit whether the Donbas could be on the table as part of US peace talks and potential NATO membership for Ukraine 4. The Telegram channel Our Wars, Today further pointed to a two-day round of negotiations in Abu Dhabi in mid-November, during which, according to Zelenskyy, the Russian side had been unwilling to discuss a de-escalation in the Black Sea and an end to energy strikes 65.

The key players in Shenzhen and Berlin

Central participants at the summit in Shenzhen were US President Donald Trump, China's head of state Xi Jinping and Russia's President Vladimir Putin 514 BFM18 France 2440 X: @CSIS41 X: @CSIS68 Telegram: The Kyiv Independent70 Kyiv Post. According to an X post by the account @sentdefender, which refers to RT, Putin and Trump exchanged a few words at the edge of a group photo session with Xi before a reception for the delegation leaders. According to this, Kremlin spokesman Dmitry Peskov stated that Putin and Xi had discussed ending Russia's war against Ukraine in their own conversations 32.

On the European side, France's President Emmanuel Macron came forward with a demand regarding the NATO membership question for Ukraine 68 RTE.ie10 Kyiv Post. According to NewsCord, US envoy Jared Kushner commented on Russian positions regarding security guarantees 7. US negotiator Steve Witkoff is quoted in X posts by think tank fellow Nico Lange with the phrasing "like Article 5" but "not NATO" 35. Political scientist Carlo Masala accused both US negotiators of lacking a plan in X posts 36.

For Germany, Chancellor Friedrich Merz appears as the host of the Berlin meeting of the Coalition of the Willing at the Chancellery 950 X: @dpa56 Tagesspiegel. According to a report by the pro-Russian Telegram channel Intel Slava, Merz is said to have indicated a gradual easing of Russia sanctions once combat operations slowed down 69. No independent confirmation of this statement is available in the available reports. According to a Polish report, Ukrainian Foreign Minister Andrij Sybiha reacted mockingly to Putin's participation in the summit. On the Ukrainian side, President Volodymyr Zelensky took part in the Berlin meeting and addressed questions about guarantees and Donbass 3766 Telegram: Military Summary.

The Shenzhen declaration and the guarantee debate in Berlin

The summit in Shenzhen took place on 19 November 2026 and resulted in a joint peace declaration by the three heads of state 1521 Le Figaro40 X: @CSIS41 X: @CSIS51 Sib.fm52 Online47.ru70 Kyiv Post. Kyiv Post reports that Putin, Trump and Xi called for UN reform and nuclear dialogue in the peace declaration 70. Following a posting via the X account @sentdefender, the White House published the joint declaration signed by Trump, Putin and Xi following their first trilateral meeting.

According to the declaration, it affirms that nuclear war cannot be won and must never be fought. It commits the three countries to dialogue on reducing nuclear risks and preventing proliferation, to UN reform and to plans for increasing production and supply of refined oil. It also states that the International Criminal Court and similar bodies must not abuse their jurisdiction 42. dpa announced in a morning tweet the three-way meeting and the Ukraine summit at Merz's Chancellor's Office as central themes of the day 50.

According to an AFP breaking news report, Trump said after the summit that Putin had expressed his desire for an end to the Ukraine war 49. According to the Telegram channel Military Summary, Trump added with regard to the talks that Putin was seriously interested in peace 67.

According to an X post by the account @sentdefender, the trilateral meeting was to cover topics such as nuclear non-proliferation, ongoing conflicts including the Middle East and Ukraine, and economic issues 43. According to the same account, which cites a US official speaking to Fox News, Trump and Putin were also to meet bilaterally on the same day 4445 X: @LucasFoxNews (via @sentdefender). CNews reports in its live ticker that Trump held a conversation with Xi Jinping after meeting with Putin 22.

According to CNews and Kyiv Independent, Trump said at the opening that they were making history 1668 Telegram: The Kyiv Independent. According to CNews he also said before Putin and Xi Jinping that they wanted to end the war in Ukraine 24. Kyiv Independent and several Telegram sources of claim report consistently that Trump referred to Putin as "my friend" 6368 Telegram: The Kyiv Independent. According to CNews, Xi Jinping called for everything to be done to prevent nuclear war 25.

According to Regards protestants, nuclear weapons and artificial intelligence were subjects of the talks. Le Parisien confirms the focus on nuclear weapons 1320 Le Parisien. RUSI pointed out before the summit that Trump wanted to raise the issue of nuclear arms reductions there 46. According to Libération, the Europeans were the great absentees from the summit 17.

Berlin meets, Trump dials in

In parallel, the coalition of the willing came together in Berlin 1150 X: @dpa56 Tagesspiegel. According to Tagesspiegel, Trump joined the meeting from Air Force One via telephone and apparently criticised the billions in aid to Kyiv 56. The Telegram channel Military Summary additionally points to a Politico report according to which Trump criticised the allocation of billions in military aid to Kyiv and portrayed Putin as seriously interested in peace 67. According to Yahoo, Chancellor Merz said at this meeting that diplomacy was the only way 9.

Macron, Kushner and the dispute over Article 5

According to France 24, RTE and Kyiv Post, Macron called on Ukraine's allies to revisit the question of NATO membership, explicitly in response to Russian demands 68 RTE.ie10 Kyiv Post. According to NewsCord, Jared Kushner stated that Russia was in agreement with NATO-like security guarantees for post-war Ukraine 7. US negotiator Steve Witkoff's formulation that the guarantees should be "like Article 5" but "not NATO" was critically commented on in an X post by Nico Lange 35.

According to a summary from the Telegram finance channel Caijing Manbao, Trump himself stated at a Friday press conference at the White House that it was too early to speak about security guarantees for Ukraine. He repeatedly evaded committing to NATO-like guarantees and justified this by saying that an agreement must first be reached 62. According to an X post by Welt, Zelensky reported a controversial US proposal for Ukraine's NATO membership in return for relinquishing the Donbas 37. Carlo Masala commented on this proposal as evidence of the lack of planning by Kushner and Witkoff 36. An article by Outlook India from 16 November discusses the same debate in principle 4.

The background to the Shenzhen meeting is a Ukrainian attack on the Kerch bridge on 17 November 2026. According to the Telegram channels Military Summary and WarGonzo (WarGonzo spreads pro-Russian war propaganda), Putin announced from China that the response to Kyiv would be "significantly more painful". According to WarGonzo, Putin additionally removed from the agenda a limited ceasefire previously discussed in the Security Council and hinted at the possible use of previously unused weapons systems 5861 Telegram: WarGonzo.

The Telegram account Military Summary also reports that France's Defence Minister confirmed that French soldiers were already on Ukrainian soil. However, independent confirmation from published sources is not available in the recent reports 58. The pro-Russian Telegram channel Intel Slava also cites a statement by Zelensky that Russia rejected all proposals for a ceasefire. It further references a statement by Trump that he had full understanding for Putin's outrage following the bridge attack 69.

Assessment and interpretation of the meeting

Russian state media TASS claims that the meeting of the heads of state of Russia, China and the USA in Shenzhen meets global expectations and cites an expert for this 1. Chinese state media Global Times presents the China-Russia-USA summit as a landmark diplomatic event for the history books 2. Chinese state news agency Xinhua (news.cn) reports in the same direction about a peace declaration by the heads of state of China, Russia and the USA 3.

Sober assessments in the West

These three accounts from state media are not evidence but rather the official interpretation of their governments. They align with Western reports in their core findings about the summit and the joint declaration 1521 Le Figaro70 Kyiv Post, but they differ in assessment and framing. Western and Polish reports characterise the summit more soberly. MILMAG speaks of a historic meeting without breakthrough 26, Centrum Europy of much ceremony and little substance 30, and Radio Zet refers to Le Figaro with the assessment that the summit marks more the end of an era than the beginning of a new order 29.

According to an article from TF1 Info, essayist Adina Revol expresses the view in the programme LCI that Putin is convinced after the summit in Shenzhen that he is sitting at the table of the great powers again 55. A Polish article quotes a former US ambassador to Poland as stating that the summit demonstrated that Europe is largely left to its own devices 27. Western think tanks express themselves cautiously in posts on X.

GMF expert Bonnie Glaser sums up the meeting according to German Marshall Fund with "Not Yalta but not nothing". The summit revealed common interests especially in nuclear risk reduction but also deep differences over Ukraine and Iran 47. Fred Kempe from the Atlantic Council writes that Trump, Putin and Xi arrived with competing ambitions and growing vulnerabilities. Their domestic and geopolitical constraints could accelerate the erosion of the global order 48.

In a preliminary analysis, the Atlantic Council discusses what the three heads of state expected from the meeting in Shenzhen, also with regard to Ukraine, Europe and US allies in the Indo-Pacific 34. Brookings experts expressed themselves similarly beforehand about possible outcomes of a Trump-Xi meeting and a possible trilateral encounter 39. Nico Lange's post on X calls for the Coalition of the Willing in Berlin to say confidently to Trump, Xi and Putin that there should be a Ukrainian solution for Ukraine and a European solution for Europe 31. This is an opinion statement without evidential character.

Russian threats and propaganda

On the Russian side, the pro-Russian Telegram channel WarGonzo (war propaganda) alleges that Moscow is preparing four possible escalation scenarios, including renewed use of the Oreshnik intermediate-range system 61. The Telegram channel of former president and current deputy chair of the Security Council Dmitry Medvedev (Russian state propaganda) questions in an older post the legitimacy of the UN Secretary-General's office and the Office of Legal Affairs. It allegedly denied the Donbas and Crimea the right to self-determination 60.

This post dates from 30 January 2026 and is not directly related to the Shenzhen summit, but it illustrates the line of argument that Russian top politicians maintain on the Donbas question. The Telegram channel OSINTdefender references a statement by Trump from 16 November in which Putin is said to be "backing off somewhat" in the Ukraine war and could have acted much more forcefully 59. The Telegram channel Military Summary references an ironic exchange between Zelenskyy and a reporter in which Zelenskyy answered the question of whether Trump had ever called him a friend with "I think so, yes, I just do not remember" and at the same time refers to Zelenskyy's request for assistance of 115 billion US dollars for the coming year 66.

What is established and what remains open

It is documented that on 19 November 2026 a trilateral meeting of Trump, Xi and Putin took place in Shenzhen and a joint peace declaration was adopted. This is supplemented by the CSIS chronology of Trump's Asia trip from 16 to 19 November 4041 X: @CSIS and by Kyiv Post, which confirms UN reform and atomic dialogue as components of the declaration 70. It is also documented that Macron demanded that the NATO membership question for Ukraine be revisited.

Details of the declaration and individual quotes

Trump's telephone connection from Air Force One to the Berlin meeting of the Coalition of the Willing and his criticism of the billions in aid for Kyiv are covered by Tagesspiegel and the reproduction of a Politico report 5667 Telegram: Military Summary. The detailed description of the declaration (formula concerning atomic war, refined petroleum, jurisdiction of international courts) relies primarily on the post by @sentdefender 42 in the available reports and is supported by Kyiv Post and dpa for the core elements UN reform and atomic dialogue 5070 Kyiv Post.

The specific formulations remain plausible in this form, but without an official full text in the reports presented. Central political claims, in particular Kushner's statement about Russian agreement to NATO-like security guarantees and Trump's cited opening words, have so far relied on one or two outlets each and supplementary Telegram channels 6368 Telegram: The Kyiv Independent. Trump's own statement at Friday's press conference that guarantees were premature comes exclusively from a Chinese Telegram finance channel and is a claim without independent confirmation in the available reports 62.

The alleged US initiative put forward by Kushner and Witkoff of "NATO accession in exchange for Donbass withdrawal" is referenced in an X post by Welt and commented on by two other X accounts 3637 X: @welt (via @CarloMasala1). A full text from a news website is not available in the available reports. Information about Putin's reaction following the attack on the Kerch Bridge on 17 November 2026 is based on two Telegram channels (Military Summary, WarGonzo) which agree in broad outline 5861 Telegram: WarGonzo.

Open questions and the force for Ukraine

A detailed report from a publishing house is missing. Reliable details are lacking in the available reports regarding concrete negotiation outcomes of the Berlin meeting, the composition of participants and official Russian reactions beyond the cited state and propaganda channels. The military underpinning of the guarantee debate is the Multinational Force Ukraine (MNF-U): since 9 November it has been rehearsing a deployment for the first time in Poland under British and French leadership, and according to Ukrainska Pravda and blue News around 2,800 troops from eleven countries are taking part in exercise Koalicja 2026 until 22 November 7172 blue News.

The force is meant to deploy only after the fighting has ended and at Kyiv's request, and it is not a NATO operation 71. Possible developments can only be outlined with reservation. They depend on whether the points laid out in the peace declaration are specified in subsequent formats and whether the debate about security guarantees and NATO accession for Ukraine finds support within the alliance.

Sources analysed for this situation, by number of news items

455 news items from 166 sources
Web 110Telegram 33X 23EN 229RU 109DE 33UK 32FR 25PL 22ZH 5

This overview shows which sources the Monitor analysed for this situation. Being listed is neither an assessment nor an endorsement.

XX: @EUvsDisinfo EN 30

News items from this source (30) x.com

XX: @GeoConfirmed EN 25

News items from this source (25) x.com

TelegramTelegram: The Kyiv Independent EN 24

News items from this source (24) t.me

TelegramTelegram: Our Wars, Today EN 22

News items from this source (22) t.me

TelegramTelegram: Military Summary EN 21

News items from this source (21) t.me

XX: @CarloMasala1 DE 16

News items from this source (16) x.com

TelegramTelegram: Kotsnews RU 11
TelegramTelegram: Readovka RU 11

News items from this source (11) t.me

TelegramTelegram: 💥BEREZOVIEW (Taras Berezovets) WAR IN UKRAINE UK 9

News items from this source (9) t.me

TelegramTelegram: Armed Forces of Ukraine - Збройні сили України . Telegram Channel by RTP [Army / Military / Navy / Air / україна] UK 9

News items from this source (9) t.me

XX: @nicolange_ DE 8
TelegramTelegram: Медуза — LIVE RU 7
TelegramTelegram: Meduza in English RU 7
TelegramTelegram: Новая газета Европа RU 7
XX: @eu_eeas EN 7
TelegramTelegram: Лачен пише UK 6
XX: @RUSI_org EN 6
XX: @TheStudyofWar EN 6
TelegramTelegram: The Moscow Times (EN) RU 6
TelegramTelegram: WarGonzo RU 5
XX: @kajakallas EN 5
TelegramTelegram: Рыбарь RU 5
XX: @sentdefender EN 5
WebCNews FR 5
WebFrance 24 FR/EN 4
XX: @AFP EN 4
XX: @AtlanticCouncil EN 4
TelegramTelegram: Санкции в РФ RU 4
TelegramTelegram: Intel Slava EN 4
TelegramTelegram: OSINTdefender EN 4
XX: @CSIS EN 3
TelegramTelegram: Интерфакс RU 3
TelegramTelegram: STERNENKO UK 3
WebKyiv Post EN 3
WebEuronews.com PL/RU 3
XX: @RALee85 EN 3
TelegramTelegram: Дмитрий Медведев RU 3
XX: @ChathamHouse EN 2
TelegramTelegram: TASS NEWS 🇷🇺 🇩🇪 RU 2
XX: @gmfus EN 2
WebTF1 Info FR 2
WebLa Croix FR 2
TelegramTelegram: Dmitry Medvedev RU 2
TelegramTelegram: Два майора RU 2
WebLe Figaro FR 2
WebLIGA.net UK 2
WebEuronews EN 2
Webaljazeera.com EN 2
TelegramTelegram: War Monitor EN 2
WebBFM FR 2
XX: @dpa DE 2
XX: @Tendar EN 2
XX: @CNASdc EN 2
XX: @KubiliusA EN 2
XX: @BrookingsInst EN 2
TelegramTelegram: 财经慢报 ZH 1

News items from this source (1) t.me

TelegramTelegram: Colonelcassad RU 1
TelegramTelegram: ТАСС RU 1
XX: @IISS_org EN 1
WebВідомо RU 1
WebThe World Inform RU 1
WebMILMAG PL 1

News items from this source (1) news.google.com

WebFacebook FR 1
WebArmiya.az RU 1
WebRegards protestants FR 1
WebLe Point FR 1

News items from this source (1) news.google.com

Webhttp://obzor.io/ RU 1
WebStooq PL 1
Web조선일보 EN 1

News items from this source (1) news.google.com

WebNewsCord EN 1
WebThe Conversation EN 1

News items from this source (1) theconversation.com

WebThe Paper / Pengpai (thepaper.cn) ZH 1

News items from this source (1) www.thepaper.cn

WebWirtualna Polska PL 1

News items from this source (1) wiadomosci.wp.pl

WebCNBC EN 1

News items from this source (1) www.cnbc.com

WebBloomberg EN 1

News items from this source (1) www.bloomberg.com

TelegramTelegram-Kanal Dmitri Medwedew RU 1

News items from this source (1) t.me

WebRzeczpospolita PL 1

News items from this source (1) www.rp.pl

Webmeduza.io RU 1

News items from this source (1) meduza.io

WebYahoo EN 1

News items from this source (1) news.google.com

Webuatv.ua RU 1
WebГазета RU 1
WebTF1+ FR 1
TelegramTelegram: Bundeswehr Militär Armee - Nachrichten und Sicherheit auf Telegram Deutschland: Heer, Luftwaffe, Marine, Polizei EN 1
WebNews.by RU 1
WebChallenges FR 1
Web24.kz RU 1
TelegramTelegram: Мир сегодня с "Юрий Подоляка" RU 1
WebDziennik.pl PL 1

News items from this source (1) news.google.com

WebRTE.ie EN 1

News items from this source (1) news.google.com

WebCentrum Europy PL 1
WebVietnam.vn PL 1
WebNV RU 1
WebСиб.фм.. RU 1
WebЭлектронная газета «Век RU 1
WebФедералПресс RU 1
XX: @EUSec_Defence EN 1
WebBFM.ru RU 1
WebOnline47.ru RU 1
WebЭХО RU 1
WebБИЗНЕС ЖУРНАЛ. ЦЕНТР RU 1
WebВедомости RU 1
Websalon24.pl PL 1

News items from this source (1) news.google.com

WebВК Пресс» Краснодар RU 1
WebНаша Ніва RU 1
Webnewizv.ru RU 1
WebREFORM.news RU 1

News items from this source (1) news.google.com

WebPolskie Radio PL 1
WebToulouse7.com FR 1

News items from this source (1) news.google.com

WebРадио Свобода RU 1
WebNewsmax Polska PL 1

News items from this source (1) news.google.com

WebRadio Zet PL 1
WebGOV.UK EN 1

News items from this source (1) www.gov.uk

WebObserwator Gospodarczy PL 1

News items from this source (1) obserwatorgospodarczy.pl

WebDeutscher BundeswehrVerband DE 1

News items from this source (1) www.dbwv.de

WebLe Figaro (ueber shango.media) FR 1
WebTagesspiegel DE 1
WebBotschaft der VR China in den USA ZH 1

News items from this source (1) us.china-embassy.gov.cn

WebTASS EN 1

News items from this source (1) tass.com

WebZDFheute DE 1

News items from this source (1) www.zdfheute.de

WebTVN24 PL 1
WebDeutschland.de EN 1

News items from this source (1) www.deutschland.de

Webbne IntelliNews EN 1

News items from this source (1) www.intellinews.com

WebVedomosti RU 1

News items from this source (1) www.google.com

WebPBS NewsHour EN 1
WebAl-Monitor EN 1

News items from this source (1) www.al-monitor.com

WebRadio Free Asia Mandarin ZH 1

News items from this source (1) www.rfa.org

WebNATO EN 1

News items from this source (1) www.nato.int

WebRMF24 PL 1

News items from this source (1) www.rmf24.pl

WebBerliner Zeitung DE 1

News items from this source (1) www.berliner-zeitung.de

Webvedomosti.ru RU 1

News items from this source (1) www.vedomosti.ru

Webrp.pl PL 1

News items from this source (1) www.rp.pl

Webglobaltimes.cn EN 1

News items from this source (1) www.globaltimes.cn

Webnzz.ch DE 1
Webrferl.org EN 1

News items from this source (1) www.rferl.org

Webkyivindependent.com EN 1

News items from this source (1) kyivindependent.com

Weblatintimes.com EN 1
Webpravda.com.ua EN 1

News items from this source (1) www.pravda.com.ua

Webbundesregierung.de DE 1

News items from this source (1) www.bundesregierung.de

Webkyivpost.com EN 1

News items from this source (1) www.kyivpost.com

Webnews.cn ZH 1

News items from this source (1) www.news.cn

Webtass.com EN 1

News items from this source (1) tass.com

WebИнтерфакс RU 1
Webspbdnevnik.ru RU 1
WebLibération FR 1

News items from this source (1) news.google.com

Web112.ua PL 1
TelegramTelegram: Defense Express UK 1
WebLe Parisien FR 1
WebDefence24 PL 1

News items from this source (1) news.google.com

Webtaz DE 1

News items from this source (1) taz.de

Webeuobserver.com EN 1
Webo2 PL 1

News items from this source (1) news.google.com

WebСеребряный Дождь RU 1
Weboutlookindia.com EN 1

News items from this source (1) www.outlookindia.com

WebRzeczpospolita (Radar) PL 1

News items from this source (1) radar.rp.pl

WebUkrinform UK 1

News items from this source (1) www.ukrinform.ua

WebJoint Forces EN 1

News items from this source (1) www.joint-forces.com

Webcnbc.com EN 1

News items from this source (1) www.cnbc.com

XX: @CarnegieEndow EN 1
TelegramTelegram: Старше Эдды RU 1
TelegramTelegram: ✙DeepState✙🇺🇦 UK 1
WebJoint Forces News EN 1

News items from this source (1) www.joint-forces.com

WebMinisterstwo Obrony Narodowej (gov.pl) PL 1

News items from this source (1) www.gov.pl

Webapnews.com EN 1
WebThe Washington Times EN 1

News items from this source (1) www.washingtontimes.com

Webgrosswald.org EN 1

News items from this source (1) www.grosswald.org

Webgov.uk EN 1

News items from this source (1) www.gov.uk

Cited sources

Footnotes from the report

  • [1] TASS https://tass.com/world/2222561
  • [2] Global Times https://www.globaltimes.cn/page/202611/1374740.shtml
  • [3] Xinhua (news.cn) https://www.news.cn/politics/leaders/20261119/52ee3a20593f4b3db7642db2a7ece1a7/c ...
  • [4] Outlook India https://www.outlookindia.com/international/ukraine-donbas-nato-membership-us-peac ...
  • [5] TF1 Info https://news.google.com/rss/articles/CBMidkFVX3lxTFBmSWNqZUVuQVgtTWxXbmtZdXVpOEFS ...
  • [6] France 24 https://news.google.com/rss/articles/CBMipgFBVV95cUxOaWREcTVUemk2U0hnMDNzQzViTVBB ...
  • [7] NewsCord https://news.google.com/rss/articles/CBMi6AFBVV95cUxQcmY5VUlHbUJ2c245TTQ4OUpJVUlK ...
  • [8] RTE.ie https://news.google.com/rss/articles/CBMijAFBVV95cUxQMTZBSnN3cXdxRkZscUV6YmJmMjZp ...
  • [9] Yahoo https://news.google.com/rss/articles/CBMilgFBVV95cUxObmFudzRIZ19YQ01DX2FpcU9UeDJz ...
  • [10] Kyiv Post https://news.google.com/rss/articles/CBMiS0FVX3lxTE1lZjhzNld6TEhEbHZwa08xcDRWRGZt ...
  • [11] Chosun Ilbo https://news.google.com/rss/articles/CBMihAFBVV95cUxPLXNnVUVmYXJTVHd6MXM1LVhVaFNK ...
  • [12] Toulouse7.com https://news.google.com/rss/articles/CBMipAFBVV95cUxQaVBRb01iMndhcDdHWjJyRnNyY25M ...
  • [13] Regards protestants https://news.google.com/rss/articles/CBMi8AFBVV95cUxQSnFMREZremNSXzNsdUthd3B0QUpC ...
  • [14] BFM https://news.google.com/rss/articles/CBMihwJBVV95cUxQaXVxVW5UVUFKTWFKbjZObDdlZ2Zt ...
  • [15] La Croix https://news.google.com/rss/articles/CBMiuwFBVV95cUxPalVBckZwNDRzVWpmRDFpYUd1dm1n ...
  • [16] CNews https://news.google.com/rss/articles/CBMiugFBVV95cUxOQnFPWGo0WUE3VkdUX2x5T01ZekdB ...
  • [17] Libération https://news.google.com/rss/articles/CBMi8wFBVV95cUxQbU5IeTJjeFctVExrV3ZmcEliVEZi ...
  • [18] France 24 https://news.google.com/rss/articles/CBMi4AFBVV95cUxNNkx4OGhsLXRrUWE5UXgyOHVic2lH ...
  • [20] Le Parisien https://news.google.com/rss/articles/CBMimwJBVV95cUxQMGRFdDQzNkVIcURmT2NiQnc3N01Z ...
  • [21] Le Figaro https://news.google.com/rss/articles/CBMijwJBVV95cUxQa29ScjdFZDJMMEowaEpyeHFCbXRv ...
  • [22] CNews https://news.google.com/rss/articles/CBMirwFBVV95cUxPSFpJWmpGTjdPS25tOG81c2RwYlBU ...
  • [24] CNews https://news.google.com/rss/articles/CBMitgFBVV95cUxPd2tuOVl1Q2x5cUxaNEFTRVZuR3RW ...
  • [25] CNews https://news.google.com/rss/articles/CBMisAFBVV95cUxNQm1TVWliZXdjMS1nNzZYT0Q3OFlf ...
  • [26] MILMAG https://news.google.com/rss/articles/CBMie0FVX3lxTE5NWG1NUUk3dngxekNQR0d6Wk1qSEc5 ...
  • [27] Stooq https://news.google.com/rss/articles/CBMiQ0FVX3lxTFB1THM4cXdQWl9MQWthSUFWbno2dEVS ...
  • [29] Radio Zet https://news.google.com/rss/articles/CBMiuwFBVV95cUxNaFV6YVdBT2dEN1JsZ3hBSTNGNmRL ...
  • [30] Centrum Europy https://news.google.com/rss/articles/CBMiswFBVV95cUxQWEhFTFVFam83anNNVnRqSVVBMjZE ...
  • [31] X: @nicolange_ https://x.com/nicolange_/status/2123265686827061744
  • [32] X: @sentdefender https://x.com/sentdefender/status/2123062891154690056
  • [33] X: @RUSI_org https://x.com/RUSI_org/status/2120101411480314204
  • [34] X: @AtlanticCouncil https://x.com/AtlanticCouncil/status/2122764880105415037
  • [35] X: @nicolange_ https://x.com/nicolange_/status/2120908897800126774
  • [36] X: @CarloMasala1 https://x.com/CarloMasala1/status/2121615442066498037
  • [37] X: @welt (via @CarloMasala1) https://x.com/welt/status/2121556905277415769
  • [38] X: @CarloMasala1 https://x.com/CarloMasala1/status/2119793943344718151
  • [39] X: @BrookingsInst https://x.com/BrookingsInst/status/2121934993672802429
  • [40] X: @CSIS https://x.com/CSIS/status/2123521696657178813
  • [41] X: @CSIS https://x.com/CSIS/status/2123521698456555695
  • [42] X: @sentdefender https://x.com/sentdefender/status/2123420616996892708
  • [43] X: @sentdefender https://x.com/sentdefender/status/2123353175390351600
  • [44] X: @sentdefender https://x.com/sentdefender/status/2123092794969620857
  • [45] X: @LucasFoxNews (via @sentdefender) https://x.com/LucasFoxNews/status/2123089419397968100
  • [46] X: @RUSI_org https://x.com/RUSI_org/status/2122373537033863214
  • [47] X: @gmfus https://x.com/gmfus/status/2123831095942598903
  • [48] X: @AtlanticCouncil https://x.com/AtlanticCouncil/status/2123073304634261830
  • [49] X: @AFP https://x.com/AFP/status/2123838277828608230
  • [50] X: @dpa https://x.com/dpa/status/2123303264536109280
  • [51] Sib.fm https://news.google.com/rss/articles/CBMivwFBVV95cUxQMlExalB2TDhJRU1wblROT0VUVmU1 ...
  • [52] Online47.ru https://news.google.com/rss/articles/CBMitAFBVV95cUxOVnlEOU9FT2trQk5RZlNTcWxUZjZT ...
  • [55] TF1 Info https://news.google.com/rss/articles/CBMivwJBVV95cUxQNzlBN3N1cC1oSlNDYlU4ZTc0LXd5 ...
  • [56] Tagesspiegel https://www.tagesspiegel.de/internationales/schimpftirade-in-der-air-force-one-tr ...
  • [58] Telegram: Military Summary https://t.me/militarysummary/33049
  • [59] Telegram: OSINTdefender https://t.me/OSINTdefender/20768
  • [60] Telegram: Dmitry Medvedev https://t.me/medvedev_telegramE/126
  • [61] Telegram: WarGonzo https://t.me/wargonzo/38535
  • [62] Telegram: Caijing Manbao https://t.me/Financial_Express/3646046
  • [63] Telegram: Our Wars, Today https://t.me/ourwarstoday/45952
  • [64] Telegram: Our Wars, Today https://t.me/ourwarstoday/45921
  • [65] Telegram: Our Wars, Today https://t.me/ourwarstoday/45908
  • [66] Telegram: Military Summary https://t.me/militarysummary/33054
  • [67] Telegram: Military Summary https://t.me/militarysummary/33047
  • [68] Telegram: The Kyiv Independent https://t.me/KyivIndependent_official/57034
  • [69] Telegram: Intel Slava https://t.me/intelslava/98319
  • [70] Kyiv Post https://www.kyivpost.com/post/90605
  • [71] Ukrainska Pravda https://www.pravda.com.ua/eng/news/2026/11/09/8061886/
  • [72] blue News https://www.bluewin.ch/en/news/2-800-soldiers-from-eleven-countries-participate-i ...

Back to the overview