Deep dive Disinformation

The Shenzhen summit was no Yalta, yet Moscow keeps the comparison alive

The Shenzhen summit is being compared with the Yalta conference of 1945. The three presidents' declaration divides nothing up and does not mention Ukraine. Putin defended Yalta all the same, Medvedev called the parallel entirely apt and Beijing rejects it. No evidence of fabricated content was found.

  • 295 news items
  • 127 sources
Three empty armchairs on a stone terrace above the sea, framed by cypress trees
Image AI-generated (AegisSight)

Data from the AegisSight Monitor. Request trial access

  • On 19 November 2026 Donald Trump, Xi Jinping and Vladimir Putin held their first three-way meeting, in Shenzhen on the margins of the APEC summit. The talks lasted about an hour and a half 3 56 72.
  • The joint declaration has four points: reform of the United Nations, more refined oil products, immunity of state officials together with a warning to the International Criminal Court, and nuclear risks. Ukraine, Iran, Taiwan, Europe and spheres of influence do not appear in it 38 71 92.
  • The comparison with the Yalta conference of 1945 shaped the coverage even before the meeting. According to Euronews, the label "Yalta 2.0" was coined by media commentators 3 74.
  • Moscow is sending two messages. Kremlin spokesman Dmitry Peskov rejected the parallel. Putin nodded when a reporter asked the question and then defended Yalta, and Dmitry Medvedev called the comparison "entirely apt" 72 76 77 79.
  • Chinese scholars and commentators reject the label, while European governments and Ukraine use it as a warning 3 9 73.
  • Experts at major think tanks largely reach the same verdict: plenty of imagery, little substance, no Yalta 45 49 75 89.
  • The sources reviewed contain no evidence of fabricated quotes, manipulated images or a coordinated campaign. What can be shown are competing interpretations, inflated side stories and Putin's familiar false claims about how the war began 58 81 87.

Yalta 1945 and the road to Shenzhen

In February 1945 Franklin D. Roosevelt, Winston Churchill and Joseph Stalin met for eight days at Yalta in Crimea to stake out the order after the Second World War 90. In Europe the name has since stood for deals struck by the great powers over the heads of smaller ones, and for the division of the continent. The US magazine The Atlantic recalled that the conference decided the fate of smaller states without asking them 75. Yalta now lies in Russian-occupied Crimea, a point Ukraine's foreign minister Andrii Sybiha alluded to after the summit 73.

How the comparison came into the world

The three-way format reportedly goes back to Putin. He is said to have proposed it to Trump in a phone call on 9 October 92, and Novaya Gazeta Europe cites the Wall Street Journal for this 80. Putin took up the image himself early on. On 4 November, visiting an exhibition at the Manege in Moscow, he said with reference to 1945 that the leaders of the three most important states had gathered to discuss how to arrange the world after the war. That is how Novaya Gazeta Europe reports it, citing Kommersant correspondent Andrei Kolesnikov 80. The Daily Beast describes Kremlin television footage showing Putin with schoolchildren on the subject of Yalta as an apparently scripted stunt 76.

Warnings before the meeting

President Volodymyr Zelensky said before the summit that Ukraine did not want a second Yalta. Sybiha said Putin could at most negotiate a fair ceasefire along the current line of contact, but not spheres of influence in Europe 74. Peskov rejected the parallels. The point was not to impose a new world order on anyone, he said, and the comparisons were "the games of political scientists" 72 74. Putin's foreign policy aide Yuri Ushakov, by contrast, said the significance and symbolism of the meeting could hardly be overstated 90.

Why Beijing avoids the label

China has a reason of its own to avoid the image. In 1945 it was not at the table, and a secret agreement at Yalta concerned Soviet rights in north-east China and the status of Outer Mongolia, as the China-Global South Project points out 9. Then there is Beijing's self-image as an advocate of the Global South: an exclusive club of great powers sits badly with its doctrine of non-interference and multilateralism 9. An analysis by the Lowy Institute noted as early as 10 November that a trilateral summit would let Washington look powerful but could cost Beijing dearly in Europe 94.

Who uses the comparison and who rejects it

  • Vladimir Putin, President of Russia: he nodded at the opening when asked about "Yalta 2.0" and asked at the press conference afterwards what had been so bad about Yalta. There had been no division of the world into spheres of influence there, he said 76 79 98.
  • Dmitry Peskov, Kremlin spokesman: before the meeting he denied that Russia wanted to revive the spirit of Yalta 72 74.
  • Dmitry Medvedev, deputy chairman of Russia's Security Council: he wrote on Telegram that the parallel with Yalta was entirely apt and that Europe was a nonentity 77.
  • Pro-Kremlin channels and military bloggers such as Readovka, Rybar and war correspondent Alexander Kots: they celebrate the "Big Three" while arguing over whether Chinese protocol slighted Putin 78 84 85.
  • Xi Jinping and China's commentators: the host was the centre of the meeting. Scholars such as Wu Xinbo of Fudan University explicitly reject the Yalta comparison 9 75.
  • Donald Trump, President of the United States: he spoke of making history and called Putin his friend in front of the cameras 56 61 69.
  • Friedrich Merz, Emmanuel Macron and Andy Burnham: the German chancellor, the French president and the British prime minister rejected any Yalta-style settlement in Berlin on the same day 3 91.
  • Volodymyr Zelensky and Andrii Sybiha: Ukraine's president and foreign minister warned against a second Yalta and said afterwards that Shenzhen had not become one 72 73 74.
  • Think tanks and exile media: Chatham House, the German Marshall Fund, the Council on Foreign Relations and Carnegie provide analysis. Meduza, Novaya Gazeta Europe, Radio Svoboda and The Moscow Times document the Russian debate 45 49 75 80 81 89.

What was said in Shenzhen and how it is being read

The three-way meeting on 19 November lasted about an hour and a half and ended with a declaration consisting of a preamble and four points 71 72. In it, the three permanent members of the Security Council commit themselves to reforming the United Nations. They intend to produce and supply more refined petroleum products. They stress the consent of states and the immunity of state officials and warn that the International Criminal Court must not abuse its jurisdiction. And they reaffirm that a nuclear war cannot be won and must never be fought 38 71 92.

What is missing from the declaration

Ukraine, Iran, Taiwan and Europe do not appear in the text, nor do borders or spheres of influence 71 90. Finland's President Alexander Stubb said after the Berlin meeting of Ukraine's supporters that a passage on Ukraine had been dropped at Washington's request because the wording had been unfortunate. He did not disclose its content. Meduza reports this, citing the newspaper Helsingin Sanomat 88.

Putin's nod and his defence of Yalta

According to the pro-Kremlin channel Readovka, the only question from the press at the opening concerned the comparison. Kommersant correspondent Andrei Kolesnikov called out to Putin, asking whether the meeting could be called "Yalta 2.0". Putin paused and nodded 78 79 98. Readovka turned this into the headline that "Yalta 2.0" had received Putin's nod 78.

At the press conference after the summit Putin went further. "What was so bad about Yalta?" he asked, and said there had been no division of the world into spheres of influence there. Yalta had simply acknowledged the realities that had emerged in the wake of the Second World War 76. As rendered by the channel Military Summary, he added that in today's conflicts the realities on the ground would also have to be accepted 97.

Peskov denies, Medvedev triumphs

The Kremlin's line is therefore not uniform. Before the meeting Peskov had denied that Russia wanted to revive the spirit of Yalta 72. On the day of the summit Medvedev wrote the opposite on his English-language Telegram channel. "The parallel with Yalta is entirely apt," he said, and only a summit of the great powers, like the one in 1945, could change the course of history. Europe's leaders had forfeited any place among those who make the decisions, and Europe was a nonentity that simply did not exist 77. Putin himself, however, also said in Shenzhen that discussing Europe's security without the Europeans was pointless, and invited European politicians to Moscow 3 90.

Pro-Kremlin channels between jubilation and irritation

In the pro-Kremlin channels, jubilation and irritation sit side by side. War correspondent Alexander Kots wrote of the beginning of the end of the unipolar world. At the same time he called it inappropriate to measure Shenzhen by the yardstick of Yalta, since the declaration contained not a single border and not a single sphere of influence 84. The military blog Rybar drew a sober balance: Russia was not isolated, but the Ukrainian question had not been raised at the summit because China had no interest in it. The more that was destroyed in Ukraine, the less worthwhile supporting it would become for the West, the channel concluded 86.

The row over protocol

Chinese protocol caused irritation. Xi met Trump in person at the aircraft, while Putin had been received the day before by Cai Qi, the fifth-ranking member of the party leadership 83. In the APEC group photo Putin stood next to Xi's wife Peng Liyuan, and at the banquet Trump sat next to Xi with Putin further away 75 82. The Telegram channel Vremennoye Pravitelstvo 2.0 wrote of China's strange diplomatic tricks 2 82.

Rybar pushed back. Some Russian channels were claiming that Xi had shown Putin his place, it wrote, whereas the line-up followed protocol because Trump was the guest of honour on a return visit after Xi's trip to the United States 85. Richard Turcsanyi, an Asia specialist interviewed by France 24, considers some of the alleged humiliations overstated. The very fact that the summit took place was a win for Putin, he said 2.

Beijing rejects the label

Wu Xinbo, dean of the Institute of International Studies at Fudan University, told the Shanghai newspaper The Paper that the meeting was "completely different from the historical Yalta Conference". The three states would not negotiate or make decisions on any major issue 9. A military affairs commentator on WeChat wrote that China opposed a "Yalta 2.0" because it rested on a flawed understanding of security. Another noted that the three today had no common enemy, only a pile of problems entangled with one another 9.

The state-run China Daily wrote that, as the main victors of the Second World War, the three countries should steadfastly safeguard the post-war international order. The Global Times called Taiwan the first red line 75. The Financial Times nevertheless headlined its report with the line that China was revelling in Xi's Yalta 2.0 moment 7.

Europe and Kyiv use the comparison as a warning

The Coalition of the Willing met in Berlin on the same day. Chancellor Friedrich Merz said: "A Yalta format will not bring peace." At Yalta, he said, Europe had been divided up, and that would not be allowed to happen again. He presented each delegation with a piece of the Berlin Wall 3 91.

French President Emmanuel Macron said he did not think Shenzhen amounted to a reorganisation of the world. British Prime Minister Andy Burnham declared that there was no decision about Ukraine without Ukraine in the room 3. Sybiha wrote on X that Shenzhen was not the Yalta of Putin's dreams and that it was time for Putin to wake up and end the war he could never win 73. Zelensky said Ukraine did not want to be divided by Russia 72.

Experts see plenty of imagery and little substance

Bloomberg analyst Adam Farrar put it briefly: "Yalta this was not." 75 Bronwen Maddox of Chatham House called the meeting no Yalta but showmanship 49. Bonnie Glaser of the German Marshall Fund summed it up as "not Yalta but not nothing" 45. At the Council on Foreign Relations, president Michael Froman wrote that allusions to Yalta 2.0 had been overblown and that optics had taken precedence over substance. His colleague Thomas Graham noted that Putin had got what he wanted with the photograph, because the image validated Russia as a great power 89. Alexander Gabuev of the Carnegie centre in Berlin told Novaya Gazeta Europe that Russia was a superpower only by the size of its strategic nuclear arsenal 80.

The press verdict

The press reached similar verdicts. Der Spiegel and the Washington Post saw Xi as the real winner, while the Telegraph wrote that Putin had got almost everything 75. La Repubblica ran a headline about three men and a feigned peace, and CNN Portugal counted three victories for Putin 93. The writer Mikhail Zygar headlined his piece for the Atlantic Council with the line that Putin did not get his Yalta but was happy nonetheless. Putin's greatest success, he wrote, was his friendly interaction with Trump 99.

Narratives and claims checked against the record

The first narrative is that of the "Big Three". Medvedev and pro-Kremlin channels portray Russia as one of three powers that determine the world order 77 84. What is documented is the image of the three presidents at one table. The declaration contains no decisions on borders, wars or spheres of influence 71.

The second narrative declares Europe superfluous. Medvedev calls Europe a nonentity, and Kots mocks that the Europeans slammed the door shut from the inside themselves 77 84. On the same day Putin said that Europe's security could not sensibly be discussed without the Europeans 90.

Trump and the comparison

No statement by Trump himself on Yalta is documented in the agency reports reviewed. Readovka wrote that Trump had said he was not thinking of the Yalta conference when he travelled to the talks 64. What is established is that he called Putin his friend and defended this the following day 61 69.

Putin's claims at the press conference

Putin reinterprets Yalta. The world was not divided up there, he says, and only the situation after the war was acknowledged 76. This is an argument about the present. Anyone who reads Yalta this way is demanding that Russia's conquests in Ukraine be accepted as reality too 97.

On the start of the war Putin repeated a familiar false claim. Russia did not start the war in Ukraine and Kyiv began it in 2014, he said at the press conference 58. On 2 March 2022 the United Nations General Assembly demanded, by 141 votes to 5 with 35 abstentions, that Russia immediately end its military operations and withdraw its forces 96.

The alleged understandings of Alaska resurfaced as well. In Shenzhen Putin again invoked compromises that Russia is said to have accepted at the Anchorage summit in August 2025, and accused Kyiv and the Europeans of being unwilling to compromise 58 95. The Institute for the Study of War speaks of non-existent agreements used by the Kremlin to distract from its refusal to take steps towards peace 95.

Side stories with a wide reach

The nuclear briefcase story originated in the orbit of Russian state television. On 18 November the State Duma deputy Yevgeny Popov, who has worked for the state broadcaster VGTRK since 2000, showed the briefcase on Telegram and spoke to the aide who carries it. Russian media picked up the video and it made headlines internationally 55 87. Peskov then dismissed the excitement: the briefcase always travelled with the president, he said, and some inexperienced reporter had put the story out there 87. Political scientist Simon Mabon told Al Jazeera the appearance was pure political theatre 55.

The airport reception, the group photo and the seating plan were read as a humiliation of Putin or defended as routine 81 82 85. The music at the airport shows how easily details slip. For Putin a piece from Tchaikovsky's Nutcracker was played instead of the national anthem. According to France 24, no anthem was played for Trump either, but the song America the Beautiful 2 82.

Digest channels mix the documented and the undocumented. Military Summary relayed Putin's threat that the response to the attacks on the Crimean Bridge would be far more painful. The same post contains statements about 15 bombers ready for launch and about French troops in Ukraine, for which the sources reviewed provide no evidence 66.

How the interpretations reach the German-speaking world

In the German-speaking world the interpretations were passed on. Eva Herman's channel strung together headlines on the "historic three-way summit", among them the question of why comparisons with Yalta might deeply unsettle some US allies 53 57. The German-language Telegram channel TASS NEWS circulated an interview by the Russian state agency TASS with the economist Jeffrey Sachs, who demanded that Washington rule out NATO membership for Ukraine and Georgia 63. The Neue Rheinische Zeitung asked whether the world was being carved up anew and Europe passed over once again 21.

What is established and what remains open

The core is established: the three presidents met, adopted four general points and did not mention Ukraine 71. In substance Shenzhen was no Yalta. Nobody drew borders, nobody distributed spheres of influence, and a conversation of an hour and a half is not an eight-day conference 90.

Who benefits from the comparison

The comparison is effective all the same. For Moscow it delivers the image of a great power on an equal footing, which in Thomas Graham's assessment is what Putin was looking for 89. European governments use it to claim their own role. Liana Fix of the Council on Foreign Relations regards the Berlin meeting as a strong signal against the reading of a new Yalta 89. The Ukrainian outlet European Pravda names the dilemma: it cannot be proven that the comparison originated in Russia, but it plays into Moscow's hands 75.

Moscow's double message

What stands out is the division of labour in Moscow. To the outside world the spokesman denies, while at home Medvedev and the pro-Kremlin channels celebrate. Putin combines the two by reinterpreting Yalta, not as a carve-up but as the acknowledgement of realities 76 77. The formula is designed to present territorial gains as a given and is likely to recur in the negotiations over Ukraine.

What is not documented

There is no evidence of fabricated quotes, manipulated images or a coordinated campaign around the summit. Radio Svoboda documents a loud but open debate on social media in which critics of the Kremlin dismiss talk of a new Yalta as propaganda chatter and mock the declaration 81. It remains unclear what the deleted passage on Ukraine said 88. Who first used the label "Yalta 2.0" cannot be determined.

China's restraint

Beijing got the stage without taking on obligations. Rejecting the Yalta image fits a policy that draws influence from restraint. That is how the political scientist Wenran Jiang describes it, in whose judgement the world on display in Shenzhen is not governed but balanced 79. Rush Doshi of the Council on Foreign Relations sees a symbolic cost for Washington. The image suggests, he writes, that the world increasingly revolves around Beijing's power and preferences 89.

What to watch now

Three things will show whether the image turns into something more. First, the continuation of the format: Putin wants it, and according to Al Jazeera Trump has invited him to the G20 summit in Miami 56 58. Second, Putin's invitation to the Europeans to come to Moscow and the response of the seven European negotiators 3. Third, the language: if the formula of acknowledged realities turns up in American proposals, Moscow will have gained more from the comparison than a photograph.

Sources analysed for this situation, by number of news items

295 news items from 127 sources
Web 82Telegram 23X 22RU 114EN 111DE 27FR 25ZH 11UK 5PL 2

This overview shows which sources the Monitor analysed for this situation. Being listed is neither an assessment nor an endorsement.

TelegramTelegram: Readovka RU 17

News items from this source (17) t.me

TelegramTelegram: Дмитрий Медведев RU 15

News items from this source (15) t.me

TelegramTelegram: Медуза — LIVE RU 11

News items from this source (11) t.me

TelegramTelegram: TASS NEWS 🇷🇺 🇩🇪 RU 10
TelegramTelegram: Рыбарь RU 10
TelegramTelegram: Kotsnews RU 10
TelegramTelegram: Military Summary EN 9
TelegramTelegram: Our Wars, Today EN 7
WebBFM FR 7
XX: @ChathamHouse EN 6
TelegramTelegram: Meduza in English RU 6
XX: @AP EN 6
TelegramTelegram: Новая газета Европа RU 5
TelegramTelegram: ТАСС RU 4
XX: @AFP EN 4
XX: @AtlanticCouncil EN 4
TelegramTelegram: Коммерсантъ RU 4
TelegramTelegram: STERNENKO UK 4
TelegramTelegram: WarGonzo RU 4
XX: @RKiesewetter DE 4
TelegramTelegram: War Monitor EN 4
TelegramTelegram: The Moscow Times (EN) RU 4
XX: @gmfus EN 3
XX: @BrookingsInst EN 3
XX: @CSIS EN 3
XX: @nicolange_ DE 3
WebFrance 24 FR/EN 3
WebFirstpost EN 3
TelegramTelegram: Intel Slava EN 3
TelegramTelegram: OSINTdefender EN 3
XX: @CarloMasala1 DE 3
XX: @Reuters DE 2
WebMeduza English EN 2
TelegramTelegram: Eva Herman Offiziell DE 2

News items from this source (2) t.me

WebLa Croix FR 2
XX: @shashj EN 2
XX: @christogrozev EN 2
WebLe Figaro FR 2
XX: @eu_eeas EN 2
WebInformat.ro EN 2
Webkyivpost.com EN 2
Webmeduza.io RU 2
XX: @FaytuksNetwork EN 2
TelegramTelegram: Мир сегодня с "Юрий Подоляка" RU 2
WebLibération FR 2
WebAl Jazeera EN 2

News items from this source (2) www.aljazeera.com

Webtagesspiegel.de DE 2
XX: @RUSI_org EN 2
Web香港01 ZH 1

News items from this source (1) news.google.com

WebEurasia Review EN 1

News items from this source (1) www.eurasiareview.com

TelegramTelegram: Colonelcassad RU 1
WebTF1 Info FR 1
WebThe National Interest EN 1

News items from this source (1) news.google.com

XX: @IISS_org EN 1
WebDW.com ZH 1

News items from this source (1) news.google.com

WebSohu ZH 1

News items from this source (1) news.google.com

WebFacebook FR 1
WebLIGA.net EN 1

News items from this source (1) news.google.com

WebYahoo Actualités FR 1

News items from this source (1) news.google.com

WebRegards protestants FR 1
WebLe Point FR 1

News items from this source (1) news.google.com

WebFinancial Times EN 1

News items from this source (1) news.google.com

XX: @TheStudyofWar EN 1
WebAsiaNews ZH 1

News items from this source (1) news.google.com

Web美国之音 ZH 1

News items from this source (1) news.google.com

WebModern Diplomacy EN 1

News items from this source (1) news.google.com

WebGlobal Research EN 1

News items from this source (1) www.globalresearch.ca

WebSputnik China ZH 1

News items from this source (1) sputniknews.cn

WebApostrophe (russische Ausgabe) RU 1
WebRadio Swoboda RU 1

News items from this source (1) www.svoboda.org

WebSouth China Morning Post EN 1

News items from this source (1) www.scmp.com

WebNews.ru RU 1
WebTelegraf (Ukraine) UK 1
Webatlanticcouncil.org EN 1

News items from this source (1) www.atlanticcouncil.org

Webcicero.de DE 1

News items from this source (1) cicero.de

Webtftc.io EN 1

News items from this source (1) www.tftc.io

Webrp.pl PL 1
Webwp.pl PL 1

News items from this source (1) wiadomosci.wp.pl

Webmiddleeasteye.net EN 1

News items from this source (1) www.middleeasteye.net

XX: @FlorianFlade DE 1
WebEuronews EN 1

News items from this source (1) news.google.com

WebTF1+ FR 1
Web中国评论 ZH 1

News items from this source (1) news.google.com

WebChallenges FR 1
WebThe Conversation EN 1
WebThe China-Global South Project EN 1
XX: @MarkGaleotti EN 1

News items from this source (1) x.com

WebRFI ZH 1

News items from this source (1) news.google.com

WebRBC-Ukraine EN 1

News items from this source (1) news.google.com

TelegramTelegram: Dmitry Medvedev RU 1
TelegramTelegram: The Kyiv Independent EN 1
WebNRhZ DE 1
WebCNews FR 1
XX: @dpa DE 1
WebPragativadi EN 1
WebAl Majalla EN 1

News items from this source (1) news.google.com

WebThe Indian Express EN 1

News items from this source (1) news.google.com

Webt-online DE 1

News items from this source (1) www.t-online.de

WebHK01 ZH 1

News items from this source (1) global.hk01.com

WebOSN Media RU 1
Webhandelsblatt.com DE 1

News items from this source (1) www.handelsblatt.com

Webrferl.org EN 1

News items from this source (1) www.rferl.org

Webeuronews.com EN 1

News items from this source (1) www.euronews.com

Webria.ru RU 1
Webde-rt.com DE 1

News items from this source (1) de-rt.com

Websputniknews.cn ZH 1

News items from this source (1) sputniknews.cn

Webshango.media FR 1

News items from this source (1) www.shango.media

Webvedomosti.ru RU 1

News items from this source (1) www.vedomosti.ru

Webukrinform.net EN 1

News items from this source (1) www.ukrinform.net

Webthewire.in EN 1

News items from this source (1) m.thewire.in

Webcfr.org EN 1

News items from this source (1) www.cfr.org

Webthemoscowtimes.com EN 1

News items from this source (1) www.themoscowtimes.com

Webwatson.ch DE 1

News items from this source (1) www.watson.ch

Webaljazeera.com EN 1

News items from this source (1) www.aljazeera.com

Webtageblatt.lu DE 1

News items from this source (1) www.tageblatt.lu

Webchathamhouse.org EN 1

News items from this source (1) www.chathamhouse.org

XX: @Tendar EN 1
WebMedium EN 1
WebDaily Sun EN 1

News items from this source (1) news.google.com

WebBBC ZH 1

News items from this source (1) news.google.com

WebHungarian Conservative EN 1
WebEscudo Digital EN 1

News items from this source (1) news.google.com

WebDiePresse.com DE 1
WebThe Moscow Times (russisch) RU 1
Webfr.qz.com FR 1

News items from this source (1) fr.qz.com

Websvoboda.org RU 1
WebFreilich-Magazin DE 1

News items from this source (1) www.freilich-magazin.com

Cited sources

Footnotes from the report

Back to the overview