Deep dive International Law and the UN

Shenzhen summit demands immunity from the ICC

The four-point declaration from the Shenzhen summit calls for UN reform and insists on the immunity of officials before the International Criminal Court, which has sought Putin under an arrest warrant since 2023. Ukraine and Iran are not mentioned. As things stand, the paper is not a treaty.

  • 244 news items
  • 113 sources
Empty courtroom with a curved judges bench and empty chairs, seen through a glass pane
Image AI-generated (AegisSight)

Data from the AegisSight Monitor. Request trial access

  • On 19 November 2026, Donald Trump, Xi Jinping and Vladimir Putin met at the margins of the 33rd APEC Summit in Shenzhen for a trilateral meeting 46 53 56 and signed a joint four-point declaration titled "Declaration for Peace" 21 25 37 52 60.
  • According to consistent reports, the declaration comprises four points, including reform of the United Nations, dialogue for reducing nuclear risks and non-proliferation, expanded supply of refined petroleum products, and an emphasis on state sovereignty and immunity of officials from the International Criminal Court 5 11 37 51 52 60.
  • The war in Ukraine as well as Iran and the Strait of Hormuz are not mentioned in the declaration 6 12 37 51 54. According to Finnish President Alexander Stubb, the United States had removed an originally planned section on Ukraine because the wording was unsatisfactory.
  • According to several consistent reports, the trilateral meeting lasted approximately one and a half hours 37 49 67. Trump referred to Putin as a "friend" 45 46 47 and stated that he hoped for an end to the war in Ukraine 45 47 61.
  • Xi Jinping called at the meeting for a complete ban and destruction of nuclear weapons and stated, according to the Telegram channel War Monitor, that nuclear war cannot be won and must not be waged 40 49.
  • An arrest warrant from the International Criminal Court has been in place against Putin since March 2023. The immunity and ICC passage is classified in Western reports as a central point of contention 4 10 51.
  • In parallel, a "Coalition of the Willing" convened in Berlin on 19 November 2026, which also included the NATO Secretary General. Federal Chancellor Friedrich Merz warned there of a "Yalta peace" and presented a piece of the Berlin Wall 22. Trump joined the Berlin meeting by telephone from Air Force One a few hours after the summit 39 and expressed scepticism, according to reports, about further billion-euro aid from Europeans to Ukraine.
  • After the summit, the Russian benchmark index MOEX fell below 2,400 points for the first time since mid-October in morning trading on 20 November 2026, according to The Moscow Times citing Interfax 69. According to several assessments, the declaration contains no agreement on arms reductions 5. According to The Bell, nuclear disarmament was addressed in public opening remarks only by Trump and Xi 49.

APEC meeting and trilateral diplomacy

The trilateral summit took place at the margins of the 33rd APEC economic meeting in Shenzhen, to which Donald Trump travelled to Asia between 16 and 19 November 2026, with a previous stop at the ASEAN summit in Manila 27 43. According to the think tank CSIS, it was the third meeting between Trump and Xi Jinping this year, following encounters in May in Beijing and in September at the White House 28.

CSIS, Al Jazeera and the Russian exile media The Bell describe the three-way meeting as the first of its kind between the heads of state of the USA, China and Russia 27 37 49, and the X account @sentdefender and the pro-Russian Telegram channel Readovka also describe the gathering as the first trilateral meeting in this configuration 56 67 68. The Telegram channel Our Wars, Today reported with reference to the New York Post as early as 14 November 2026 that the first trilateral meeting in this configuration was being prepared 44.

Preparation and expectations before the summit

On the eve of the summit, according to the X account @sentdefender citing Fox News, it was expected that Trump and Putin would also meet bilaterally on 19 November 2026 at the margins of the APEC in Shenzhen 57 58. The pro-Russian Telegram channel Readovka reported that Trump had announced two meetings with Putin as part of the APEC summit and that the bilateral talks with the Russian delegation (Lavrov, Siluanov, Ushakov, Dmitriev) and US side (Rubio, Bessent) had already begun on the morning of 19 November 2026 63.

The arrest warrant against Putin

An arrest warrant has been in place against Vladimir Putin by the International Criminal Court since March 2023. The passage on immunity of state officials and the exercise of ICC jurisdiction is thus directly connected to a question that Russia, but also the USA (which have not acceded to the Rome Statute), have viewed critically for years 4 11 51.

Several think tanks had already classified expectations before the summit. The Brookings Institution published an outlook on 18 November 2026 for the APEC meeting and the possible gathering of Trump, Xi and Putin 23 33 50. The French Fondation pour la Recherche Stratégique analysed the strategic implications of a trilateral summit 16. The Atlantic Council described the three heads of state before the summit as travelling to Shenzhen with "competing ambitions and growing vulnerabilities" and warned that the gathering could accelerate the "unravelling of the global order" 35 36. The British Royal United Services Institute (RUSI) focused a supporting analysis on European nuclear deterrence, specifically the first French-British nuclear air exercise "Operation Rummy" 34.

Shortly before the summit, according to the Telegram channel OSINTdefender, Federal Chancellor Friedrich Merz had urged Donald Trump not to take any "unexpected steps" at the meeting and to continue support for European allies and Ukraine 48. The Telegram channel OSINTdefender also reported on 16 November 2026 with attribution that Trump had stated Putin "is backing down a bit in the Ukraine war" and could have acted significantly more forcefully 64.

Trump, Xi and Putin sign the declaration

Trump, Xi Jinping and Putin appeared in Shenzhen as signatories of the joint declaration 21 37 52 60. The documentation of the wording was provided through, among others, the Tagesspiegel, which published the final declaration in full text 21, the Berliner Zeitung, which notes that China published the "peace declaration" with four points 25, and according to the Russian exile media The Bell, the Kremlin on kremlin.ru 37.

The Washington Post reported on 19 November 2026 that the three heads of state had agreed to work jointly to reduce constraints on their power 60. The US newspaper The Hill summarised five central findings of the summit 70. The British The Independent reported on the four-point declaration and the absence of concrete plans to end ongoing wars 51. The public broadcaster Austrian ORF titled its analysis "Much intent, no commitments" 54.

Who is reporting on the declaration

On the Chinese-language side, Pulse HK News (critical of Beijing) 1 and VOA Chinese (foreign broadcaster financed by the US Congress) 2 report on the end of the three-way talks. Russian accounts come, among others, from Lenta.ru, a state-aligned medium 3, which can only be quoted with attribution, as well as from the pro-Russian Telegram channel Readovka 61 62 63 67 68. The Russian exile media The Bell summarises the course and text of the declaration from an opposition perspective 37 49. The Kremlin-critical Telegram channels Meduza Live 59 65 and Novaya Gazeta Europe 66 report from an opposition perspective on the summit and its consequences.

In the Western media sector, Foreign Policy 8, Politico 4, The Independent 11 51, Kyiv Post 12, the public broadcaster SRF 38, the ORF 54, the Washington Post 60, The Hill 70 and numerous news aggregator websites report on the declaration 5 6 7 9 10 13 14 15. The French Presse-citron summarises the "four resolutions" 29. Il Mattino and Challenges TN contextualise the meeting between symbolism and open questions 18 19. Think tanks such as Brookings, Atlantic Council and RUSI commented before and at the margins of the summit 23 33 34 35 36 50. The X account @sentdefender covered the meeting with several situation reports 52 53 56 57 58.

The Coalition of the Willing in Berlin

In parallel, a "Coalition of the Willing" met in Berlin under the hosting of Chancellor Friedrich Merz 22. According to the Tagesspiegel, Merz presented a piece of the Berlin Wall there 22 and warned against a "Yalta peace" 22. According to US Special Envoy Jared Kushner, as reported by the Telegram channel War Monitor, Trump joined the Berlin meeting by telephone following the Shenzhen talks 39. EU foreign affairs chief Kaja Kallas had already emphasised the importance of the ICC for the prosecution of war crimes at the G7 foreign ministers meeting in Paris on 10 November 2026 30.

The four-point declaration from Shenzhen

According to consistent reports, the three heads of state signed a four-point declaration titled "Declaration for Peace" in Shenzhen on 19 November 2026 21 25 37 52 60. According to the Russian exile media outlet The Bell, the conversation lasted approximately one and a half hours and was confirmed by reference to CNN and Kremlin spokesman Dmitri Peskow 37 49. The pro-Russian Telegram channel Readovka also reported a duration of approximately one and a half hours 67. According to The Bell, the declaration consists of a preamble and four short points 37.

The four points of the declaration

  1. Reform of the United Nations 5 11 12 13 37 52
  2. Dialogue for the reduction of nuclear risks and non-proliferation 5 17 20 37 52
  3. Expansion of the supply of refined petroleum products or strengthening of energy flows 5 7 37 52
  4. Preservation of state sovereignty and immunity of government officials against the International Criminal Court 4 5 11 37 52

The X account @sentdefender summarised with attribution that the White House had published the joint declaration signed by Trump, Putin and Xi. It affirmed that nuclear war could not be won and must never be fought, and committed the three countries to UN reform, an expansion of the production and supply of refined petroleum products, and to ensuring that the ICC and similar bodies do not abuse their jurisdiction 52.

Conspicuous gaps in the declaration

According to consistent reports, the declaration contains neither a passage about the war in Ukraine nor about Iran or the Strait of Hormuz 6 12 37 51 54. The British Independent writes in its headline that Trump, Putin and Xi target the UN and ICC in a four-point "peace declaration" but offer no plans to end wars 51. ORF titles its summary as "Much intent, no commitments" 54. According to Finnish President Alexander Stubb, the United States had a previously planned Ukraine section removed due to unsatisfactory wording.

Independent confirmation from the White House, Kremlin or Chinese Foreign Ministry is not documented in the sources available. However, according to The Bell, Putin reported that much attention was devoted to Ukraine during the morning bilateral conversation with Trump on the initiative of the US President 37.

According to The Bell, only Trump, not Putin, raised the topic of nuclear disarmament in the opening speeches. Xi Jinping joined in and called for a complete ban and destruction of nuclear weapons 49. The Telegram channel War Monitor quotes Xi as saying that nuclear war cannot be won, must not be fought and that "everything possible" must be done to prevent it 40. According to the Telegram channel OSINTdefender, Trump said the three countries were in a "unique position" to discuss the reduction of nuclear weapons and added that Iran must not acquire nuclear weapons 47.

The pro-Russian Telegram channel Readovka reported that Putin thanked Xi for organising the meeting and proposed global and regional political relations as well as energy security for discussion. He emphasised that the task of the three powers was the preservation and strengthening of the system of international law 68.

Trump referred to Putin as a "friend" in his opening remarks at the meeting 45 46 47 and stated that he hoped Putin and "the other side" wanted to end the war in Ukraine 45 47. At the start of the conversation, Trump said according to the Ukrainian media outlet The Kyiv Independent "We are really making history" 46. After the summit, according to the pro-Russian Telegram channel Readovka, Trump said that Putin had clearly expressed the desire for a diplomatic settlement of the Ukraine conflict, negotiations were going very well and the chances of agreement were high.

Trump described the trilateral meeting as "fantastic" and spoke of "excellent relations" between the heads of state of Russia, China and the United States 61. According to the same account, Trump called the United States, Russia and China the three most powerful states in the world, including technologically 61.

According to the pro-Russian Telegram channel Readovka, Putin stated after the summit that Moscow was prepared to discuss its "legitimate demands" in the field of European security and had already agreed to the compromises proposed by Washington in Anchorage. However, Kyiv and Europe were not prepared to do so 62. Putin also rejected reports that Russia was tightening its demands in Ukraine negotiations 62. The Telegram channel Our Wars, Today quotes Putin as saying "We did not start any wars" and that Russia had been trying to resolve the Ukraine crisis for eight years 55.

According to the same account, Putin spoke of hope for further progress and said "only God knows what happens next" 55. The Kremlin-critical Telegram channel Meduza Live summarised the situation on the evening of 19 November 2026 by reference to its own reports. The three heads of state had met. The joint declaration demands that the ICC does not abuse its competence in prosecuting heads of state and government. An arrest warrant against Putin has been in force since 2023. Putin stated that Russia would not give ground on the territorial question and would respond "painfully" to attacks on the Crimea Bridge 59.

Markets, tankers and the response from Berlin

According to Plataforma Media and other reports, the declaration does not provide for arms reduction 5. Yahoo News New Zealand summarises the declaration as follows. The heads of state target the UN and ICC but put forward no concrete plans to end ongoing wars 10. The Independent and ORF confirm this assessment 51 54.

Russian stock markets reacted sceptically. According to the Kremlin-critical Telegram channel The Moscow Times (EN), by reference to MOEX data and Interfax, the Russian benchmark index MOEX fell below 2,400 points for the first time since mid-October in morning trading on 20 November 2026. The Moscow Times attributes the decline to disappointed expectations regarding progress in the war in Ukraine 69.

On 20 November 2026, the Kremlin-critical Telegram channels Meduza Live and Novaya Gazeta Europe reported by reference to The Maritime Executive that four tankers that Russia was supposed to send to the United States as part of a diesel deal between Trump and Putin had not arrived in US ports. Two tankers, Leruo under Sierra Leone flag and Primorye under Russian flag, had reached the anchorage position Itacoatiara in Brazil. A third, Beast under Sierra Leone flag, was moving along the South American coast. The fourth was in the Atlantic 65 66.

In parallel, the "Coalition of the Willing" met in Berlin. Tagesspiegel reports that Merz presented a piece of the Berlin Wall there and appealed to Putin 22. According to fact-checking, the warning against a "Yalta peace" is documented in a dpa message and in Tagesspiegel. According to US Special Envoy Jared Kushner, as reported by the Telegram channel War Monitor, Trump called the Berlin meeting of European allies on Ukraine following the Shenzhen talks 39.

According to Politico, Trump expressed scepticism about further billion-euro aid from Europeans for Ukraine during this call. A follow-up report by Tagesspiegel characterises the summit as being "a success only for China" 24. The Swiss public broadcaster SRF quoted an expert on 20 November 2026 as assessing the three-way summit as "a threatening message" for Europe 38.

According to an Anadolu report documented in the fact-checking, the United Nations defended the ICC as crucial for international justice after the summit. Confirmation from a second independent source is not available in the reports available.

At the margins of the summit, according to an AP report quoted by the Telegram channel Our Wars, Today, two Russian nuclear-capable bombers left Vietnam after landing in Da Nang, which was interpreted as a sign of Moscow's military reach in Asia 42.

Interpretations in the media and think tanks

The Russian state-aligned outlet Lenta.ru presents the declaration as a "historic summit" and highlights what Putin, Trump and Xi have "agreed" on 3. The presentation is recorded only with attribution and is not substantiated. Pulse HK News (critical outlet) formulates bluntly that the three heads of state have effectively "pardoned" Putin with the declaration and rejected ICC jurisdiction 1. This formulation too is an editorial classification rather than a neutral statement of fact.

Russian and Kremlin-critical readings

The pro-Russian Telegram channel Readovka foregrounds Trump's positive assessment and quotes him as saying that the trilateral meeting in Shenzhen was "one of the most important events in years" and that the previous US administration had worked "extremely badly" on the Ukraine question 61. The same channel reports that Putin stressed Russia had already engaged with US compromise proposals in Anchorage, but Kyiv and the European governments had no interest in ending hostilities because they would then have to hold elections 62. The pro-Russian channel thus frames the summit as an opportunity for agreement that fails only because of Kyiv and Europe.

The Telegram channel Our Wars, Today repeats Putin's formula that Russia did not start the war but has tried to end it, and accuses Kyiv of triggering the crisis in south-eastern Ukraine in 2014 55. This portrayal is a classic Russian war narrative and is recorded only with attribution.

The Russian exile media outlet The Bell describes the summit under the headline "Putin, Trump and Xi Jinping have adopted the peace declaration. There is not a word about Ukraine in it" and stresses that Putin did not address the topic of nuclear disarmament in his opening remarks 37 49. The Kremlin-critical Telegram channel Meduza Live points sharply to the ICC arrest warrant against Putin and to the fact that Russia will not make concessions on the territorial question 59. Both representations are recorded with attribution.

The Telegram channels Meduza Live and Novaya Gazeta Europe (Kremlin-critical) present the diesel tanker story as evidence that the announced energy delivery to the United States did not take place as agreed but that the shipments were diverted to Brazil 65 66. In both cases the information comes from The Maritime Executive, though no official confirmation is available.

The Telegram channel "War Monitor" quotes an AP report according to which China and Russia stated that they had reached agreement with the United States on UN reforms, improved fuel supply and dialogue on nuclear risks 20. The same channel reports, citing Kushner, on Trump's telephone call during the Berlin coalition meeting 39 and quotes Xi with his warnings about nuclear war 40. The Telegram channel "Our Wars, Today" refers to a report from pravda.com.ua and summarises that Trump, Xi and Putin had endorsed a joint peace declaration without a Ukraine clause 26.

The same channel reports, citing AP, on Trump's Asia trip 31 43 and Russian bombers in Vietnam 42, and also reports, citing the New York Post, on planned consultations on nuclear arms control 44. The Telegram channel "OSINTdefender" reproduces Trump's statements on nuclear arms control and on Iran 47 as well as Merz's appeal to Trump before the summit 48, and additionally the pre-summit statement that Putin was "backing down a little" in the Ukraine war 64.

The X account @sentdefender documents before and after the summit the planned Trump-Putin bilateral meeting 57 58, the launch of the trilateral round 53 56 and the publication of the declaration by the White House 52. The Ukrainian media outlet The Kyiv Independent, through its Telegram channel, reports on Trump's "friend" remark and his Ukraine reference 45 46 as well as on Beijing's expectations for the summit 32. All of these representations come from assertion sources and are recorded only with attribution. In substance they correspond with the substantiated main points of the declaration.

Think tank analyses

The CSIS X account classifies the meeting as "the first trilateral meeting of the three heads of state" 27 28. The Brookings Institution X account promoted before the summit analyses on possible outcomes of a Trump-Xi meeting and a trilateral meeting, as well as an analysis by Patricia Kim 33 50. The Atlantic Council X account described the heads of state as arriving with competing ambitions and growing vulnerabilities and linked this to concerns about the global order 35 36.

The RUSI X account brought European nuclear deterrence into focus 34. All of these classifications are recorded as assertions. The European External Action Service (EEAS) X account had already stressed on 10 November 2026 that the ICC must prosecute war crimes when states do not 30. This position stands in clear contrast to the Shenzhen declaration.

Reliability, gaps and possible consequences

The Shenzhen meeting and the Four Point Declaration are substantively documented in terms of date, location, participants and basic structure. The four substantive points are consistently mentioned in numerous Western, Chinese language, Russian and European reports. With The Independent 51, Washington Post 60, The Hill 70 and ORF 54, there are now additional editorially independent reports available that support the Four Point core. However, the individual formulations in the fact check are still classified as "unconfirmed" because they are still mainly based on secondary reports and not on an official primary publication by the three governments that is systematically compared in the sources presented.

Reliability of the declaration and its points

With The Bell's reference to the publication on kremlin.ru 37, the verbatim reproduction in Tagesspiegel 21 and the documentation by the White House (reproduced via @sentdefender 52), primary source references are evident. A systematic text synopsis of the three government versions is still not available, however.

The absence of Ukraine, Iran and the Strait of Hormuz from the text is documented multiple times 37 51 54. This omission is marked by Western observers (Yahoo News New Zealand, SRF, Independent, ORF) as a key gap 10 38 51 54. Stubbs' statement about a deleted Ukraine section comes from several media reports but not from an official confirmation by the governments involved. A final assessment of why and by whom exactly the passage was deleted is not possible on the basis of the sources presented.

International law, markets and next steps

The ICC passage touches on a legally sensitive question under international law, particularly in light of the arrest warrant against Putin. Western positions, such as those of EU Foreign Affairs Representative Kaja Kallas from 10 November 2026 30, stand in open contradiction to the Shenzhen formulation. The Berlin Coalition of the Willing summit with its warning against a "Yalta Peace" and the symbolic piece of wall can be understood as a visible counterpoint by European states. Trump's telephone participation from Air Force One 39 and his sceptical comments on further billion dollar aid underscore the transatlantic line of tension.

The market reaction in Moscow with the MOEX sliding below 2,400 points on 20 November 2026 69 suggests that investors regard the summit as having no substantive consequences for the war in Ukraine. The reports of diesel tankers diverted to Brazil 65 66 have so far only been documented through Kremlin-critical Telegram channels and The Maritime Executive and require further verification. If confirmed, this would suggest that the expansion of crude oil product flows announced in the declaration also involves logistical detours.

Possible further developments concern above all the question of whether and how the three states will operationally implement their announcements for energy supply, nuclear dialogue and UN reform. They also concern how the G4 and other UN members will react and what concrete steps will follow from the Berlin round. The sources presented do not contain reliable information about legal binding status as treaty, memorandum or political declaration. Based on current information, this is a political declaration rather than an international legal treaty.

Sources analysed for this situation, by number of news items

244 news items from 113 sources
Web 76Telegram 23X 14RU 88EN 78DE 27UK 26ZH 15FR 10

This overview shows which sources the Monitor analysed for this situation. Being listed is neither an assessment nor an endorsement.

TelegramTelegram: Дмитрий Медведев RU 12

News items from this source (12) t.me

TelegramTelegram: Readovka RU 11

News items from this source (11) t.me

TelegramTelegram: Медуза — LIVE RU 10

News items from this source (10) t.me

TelegramTelegram: Новая газета Европа RU 10

News items from this source (10) t.me

TelegramTelegram: Генеральний штаб ЗСУ UK 10

News items from this source (10) t.me

TelegramTelegram: Интерфакс RU 8

News items from this source (8) t.me

TelegramTelegram: 财经慢报 ZH 8
TelegramTelegram: Our Wars, Today EN 7
TelegramTelegram: The Bell RU 6
TelegramTelegram: The Moscow Times (EN) RU 5
XX: @sentdefender EN 5
TelegramTelegram: InformNapalm UK 5
XX: @AFP EN 4
TelegramTelegram: ТАСС RU 4
TelegramTelegram: ВЕДОМОСТИ RU 4
TelegramTelegram: War Monitor EN 4
TelegramTelegram: Meduza in English RU 4
TelegramTelegram: STERNENKO UK 3
XX: @nicolange_ DE 3
TelegramTelegram: Коммерсантъ RU 3
Webt-online DE 3
WebTagesspiegel DE 3
TelegramTelegram: Forbes Ukraine UK 3
TelegramTelegram: OSINTdefender EN 3
XX: @CarloMasala1 DE 3
TelegramTelegram: The Kyiv Independent EN 3
TelegramTelegram: 💥BEREZOVIEW (Taras Berezovets) WAR IN UKRAINE UK 3
TelegramTelegram: TASS NEWS 🇷🇺 🇩🇪 RU 2
XX: @gmfus EN 2
WebThe Independent EN 2
WebThe Sunday Guardian EN 2
Webtaz DE 2
WebFondation pour la Recherche Stratégique FR 2
WebAtlantic Council EN 2

News items from this source (2) www.atlanticcouncil.org

XX: @CSIS EN 2
TelegramTelegram: Санкции в РФ RU 2
XX: @AtlanticCouncil EN 2
XX: @BrookingsInst EN 2
XX: @Reuters DE 1
XX: @IISS_org EN 1
WebThe Avenue Mail EN 1

News items from this source (1) news.google.com

WebYahoo News New Zealand EN 1
WebNewsCord EN 1
WebIl Mattino FR 1

News items from this source (1) news.google.com

WebChallenges TN FR 1
WebGlobal Times EN 1

News items from this source (1) www.globaltimes.cn

WebORF.at DE 1

News items from this source (1) orf.at

WebZDFheute DE 1

News items from this source (1) www.zdfheute.de

WebSüdostschweiz DE 1

News items from this source (1) www.suedostschweiz.ch

WebKorrespondent.net RU 1

News items from this source (1) korrespondent.net

WebEU Today EN 1

News items from this source (1) eutoday.net

WebEnergy News Beat EN 1

News items from this source (1) energynewsbeat.co

WebSina (zitiert Xinhua und offizielle Kanäle) ZH 1

News items from this source (1) www.sina.cn

WebExpert.ru RU 1
Web360.ru RU 1
WebSRF DE 1

News items from this source (1) www.srf.ch

WebNZZ DE 1

News items from this source (1) www.nzz.ch

WebAsiaNews ZH 1

News items from this source (1) asianews.it

WebStuttgarter Zeitung DE 1

News items from this source (1) www.stuttgarter-zeitung.de

WebYahoo News Canada / The Independent EN 1

News items from this source (1) ca.news.yahoo.com

WebAsia Times EN 1

News items from this source (1) asiatimes.com

WebPolitis (Zypern) EN 1

News items from this source (1) en.politis.com.cy

WebTelepolis DE 1

News items from this source (1) www.telepolis.de

WebOberösterreichische Nachrichten DE 1

News items from this source (1) www.nachrichten.at

WebCensor.net UK 1
WebUNIAN UK 1
WebChallenges Tunisia FR 1
WebThe Conversation EN 1

News items from this source (1) theconversation.com

WebReuters via Yahoo News EN 1

News items from this source (1) www.yahoo.com

WebUkrainska Pravda (English) EN 1

News items from this source (1) www.pravda.com.ua

WebPresse-citron FR 1

News items from this source (1) www.presse-citron.net

WebSouth China Morning Post EN 1

News items from this source (1) www.scmp.com

WebLenta.ru RU 1
Webnews.qq.com (CCTV / Tencent) ZH 1

News items from this source (1) news.qq.com

WebVietnam.vn FR 1
WebPlataforma Media EN 1
Webwww.nationpathindia.com EN 1
WebInternational Business Times, Singapore Edition EN 1
WebKyiv Post EN 1

News items from this source (1) news.google.com

WebPolitico EN 1

News items from this source (1) news.google.com

XX: @dpa DE 1
WebKommersant RU 1
WebUnited Daily News ZH 1

News items from this source (1) udn.com

WebWashington Post EN 1

News items from this source (1) www.washingtonpost.com

WebNATO EN 1

News items from this source (1) www.nato.int

WebUkrinform EN 1

News items from this source (1) www.ukrinform.net

WebThe Hill EN 1
WebCBC News EN 1
WebTIME EN 1

News items from this source (1) time.com

WebBotschaft der Volksrepublik China in den USA ZH 1

News items from this source (1) us.china-embassy.gov.cn

WebFranceinfo FR 1

News items from this source (1) www.franceinfo.fr

WebRadio-Canada FR 1

News items from this source (1) ici.radio-canada.ca

WebVedomosti RU 1

News items from this source (1) www.vedomosti.ru

WebRTS FR 1
WebNikkei Asia EN 1

News items from this source (1) asia.nikkei.com

WebThe Moscow Times EN 1

News items from this source (1) www.themoscowtimes.com

Webmy.ua RU 1
Webdpa via Yahoo Deutschland DE 1

News items from this source (1) de.nachrichten.yahoo.com

WebBundesregierung DE 1

News items from this source (1) www.bundesregierung.de

WebAnadolu Agency EN 1
WebThe Kyiv Independent EN 1

News items from this source (1) kyivindependent.com

WebRFE/RL EN 1

News items from this source (1) www.rferl.org

WebTASS EN 1

News items from this source (1) tass.com

Webenglish.www.gov.cn EN 1

News items from this source (1) english.www.gov.cn

Webwhitehouse.gov EN 1

News items from this source (1) www.whitehouse.gov

WebBerliner Zeitung DE 1

News items from this source (1) www.berliner-zeitung.de

WebForeign Policy EN 1

News items from this source (1) foreignpolicy.com

WebPulse HK News ZH 1
WebVOA Chinese ZH 1

News items from this source (1) www.voachinese.com

XX: @JPN_PMO EN 1

News items from this source (1) x.com

WebBrookings Institution EN 1

News items from this source (1) www.brookings.edu

XX: @RUSI_org EN 1
XX: @eu_eeas EN 1

News items from this source (1) x.com

Cited sources

Footnotes from the report

Back to the overview