Deep dive Nuclear Weapons and Arms Control

Shenzhen summit yields only a pledge of dialogue on nuclear weapons

At the Shenzhen summit, Trump, Putin and Xi reaffirmed that a nuclear war must never be fought and announced a dialogue on nuclear risks. The declaration contains no ceilings or deadlines. Since New START expired in February 2026, the arsenals of the United States and Russia have had no treaty limits.

  • 214 news items
  • 107 sources
Dark submarine moored at the pier of a naval base, the quay lights reflected in the calm water
Image AI-generated (AegisSight)

Data from the AegisSight Monitor. Request trial access

First meeting of the nuclear powers

The meeting took place as part of the 33rd Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation summit in Shenzhen 3038 X: @sentdefender53 Radio Free Europe/Radio Liberty. According to the CSIS think tank, Trump and Xi had previously met in Beijing in May and in the White House in September. The Shenzhen meeting was the third encounter between the two in that year and also the first summit of all three heads of state 2150 X: @CSIS53 Radio Free Europe/Radio Liberty. The Brookings Institution assessed in a preview from 17 November 2026 that the three heads of state travelled to Shenzhen with very different agendas 52.

The Swiss business newspaper Bilan described on 18 November 2026 the mutually opposed agendas of Putin, Trump and Xi 62. The regime-critical Russian-language broadcaster Radio Svoboda published a preview on 18 November 2026 with expectations for the meeting 70.

Arms control after the end of New START

According to the International Institute for Strategic Studies (IISS), the meeting took place at a particularly sensitive moment for global nuclear arms control. With the expiry of the New-START Treaty from 2010 on 5 February 2026, the United States and Russia are for the first time in decades free to expand their strategic nuclear arsenals without contractual limits 22. The specialist journal Arms Control Today reported in March 2026 that the United States pushed for a modernised treaty after the expiry 54.

The US specialist organisation Nuclear Threat Initiative described in early February 2026 the transition from limits to emerging risks 55. The transatlantic think tank CEPA spoke of the beginning of the end of strategic arms control 56. The Finnish foreign policy institute FIIA analysed the treaty's expiry on 20 February 2026 57. The IISS points out in an analysis from 20 November 2026 that budgetary constraints could slow greater expansion, whilst the development of missile defence makes the strategic balance more complex 22.

SIPRI reported in its yearbook in June 2026 a stronger focus on nuclear weapons with increased escalation risks 58. The specialist journal Bulletin of the Atomic Scientists already described China's nuclear weapons programme in a review article in 2025 59. A UN press release from 26 May 2026 notes that the review conference on the Nuclear Non-Proliferation Treaty ended without consensus 60. The disarmament-oriented NGO ICAN describes the same outcome as an end without a disarmament plan 61.

Expectations before the meeting

In advance, according to the Ukrainian news website Ukrainska Pravda and a New York Post report taken up by the OSINT aggregator Our Wars Today on 14 November, the meeting had been announced as the first trilateral summit where preparations for an agreement to control nuclear weapons were also to be discussed 27. The same aggregator referred in a later report to a PBS article from 16 November 2026, according to which Trump wanted to combine economic deals in Manila and Shenzhen with historic trilateral nuclear talks with Russia and China 35.

The OSINT aggregator Our Wars Today also reports, citing Associated Press, that on 19 November 2026 two Russian nuclear-capable bombers left Vietnam after they had previously landed in Da Nang 51.

Actors and international reactions

Trump, Putin and Xi took part in the trilateral meeting 2021 X: @CSIS38 X: @sentdefender53 Radio Free Europe/Radio Liberty64 Ukrainska Pravda. On the Chinese side, Foreign Minister Wang Yi accompanied the meeting, as reported by the pro-Russian Telegram channel Intel Slava 19.

Institutes put the summit in context

The Center for Strategic and International Studies (CSIS) in Washington places the meeting within the ongoing US-China relationship development and has published accompanying analyses on ASEAN, Quad, APEC and trilateral meetings 2021 X: @CSIS50 X: @CSIS. The IISS provides an assessment with a focus on nuclear arms control 22. The Fondation pour la Recherche Stratégique in France addresses strategic balance questions according to its title 14. The Brookings Institution provided a preview of the different expectations of the three state leaders 52.

The Atlantic Council points in two contributions to competing objectives and growing vulnerabilities of the three state leaders as well as possible consequences for Ukraine, Europe and US allies in the Indo-Pacific 4142 X: @AtlanticCouncil. The British Royal United Services Institute (RUSI) also looks at Europe's own deterrence and points to the first joint French-British nuclear air exercise Operation Rummy, which could deepen bilateral deterrence and serve as a template for broader European nuclear cooperation 40. Chatham House notes that the meeting gives many countries reason to stand together against the three powers 43.

Expert contributions are available from the US specialist journal Arms Control Today 54, the US specialist organisation NTI 55, the transatlantic think tank CEPA 56, the Finnish foreign policy institute FIIA 57, the international peace research institute SIPRI 58 and the Bulletin of the Atomic Scientists 59. Reporting on the NPT Review Conference comes from the official UN document 60 and the disarmament-oriented NGO ICAN 61.

Reports on the declaration and the Berlin coalition

On the Berlin coalition of the willing, reporting comes from the government information service deutschland.de 65 and the Ukrainian state agency Ukrinform 66. Reporting on the declaration relies largely on a version of the joint text published by the White House, which the X account @sentdefender cites for example 2338 X: @sentdefender. The US-funded foreign broadcaster Radio Free Europe/Radio Liberty also reproduces the four-point declaration 53, as does the Ukrainian quality newspaper Ukrainska Pravda 64 and the Ukrainian business media Forbes Ukraine 63. Reuters quoted Trump on his assessment of the prospects of success for an agreement. The X account @OSINTdefender reproduces several verbatim statements from Trump from the meeting 36.

Summit talks without nuclear agreement

The meeting in Shenzhen took place according to several independent sources and lasted approximately 90 minutes according to the Russian business media The Bell (in exile) and the Kremlin-critical Moscow Times, and the Kremlin-critical Meduza also speaks of one and a half hours 2629 Telegram: Meduza Live30 Telegram: The Moscow Times (EN). A differing account gives around 70 minutes, so the exact duration is not established.

Kremlin spokesperson Dmitry Peskov announced according to The Bell that the concluding statement had been accepted and would be published shortly 26. According to the X account @sentdefender, Peskov also stated that Putin and Xi had discussed ending the Russian war against Ukraine in their own talks 39. The contents of the statement, according to the version published by the White House as documented by @sentdefender, include an affirmation that nuclear war cannot be won and must never be waged, a commitment to dialogue on reducing nuclear risks and preventing proliferation, a commitment to UN reform, plans to increase production and supply of refined petroleum products, and a statement that the International Criminal Court and similar bodies must not abuse their jurisdiction 2333 Telegram: Military Summary.

Radio Free Europe/Radio Liberty also reports a four-point statement following the first trilateral meeting 53. Ukrainska Pravda confirms the signing of a peace declaration 64. The OSINT aggregator Our Wars Today summarised with reference to pravda.com.ua that the statement was agreed without a passage on Ukraine 49. Forbes Ukraine explicitly emphasises in its reporting what was not said about Ukraine 63.

Trump calls an agreement very hard

Trump told Reuters after the summit that reaching an agreement on limiting nuclear weapons with China and Russia was very difficult. At the meeting itself, the X account @OSINTdefender quotes him as saying that peace will never be achieved through missed opportunities, that the three countries are in a unique position to discuss reducing nuclear weapons, and that Iran must not acquire nuclear weapons. It also quotes him as saying that he had discussed ending the war in Ukraine in individual talks with Putin and hoped that the situation would change 36.

The Bell reports that whilst nuclear disarmament was a topic in the opening statements, in this phase only Trump and Xi engaged with it, whilst the topic was not initially taken up by Putin in the public phase 26.

Several reports describe that the summit ended without a Ukraine agreement and without a new nuclear arms control treaty, although security, Iran and arms reduction were on the agenda 48. The German news portal t-online described the outcome on 20 November 2026 in a commentary headline as an embarrassment 67. ZDFheute spoke on 19 November 2026 of much symbolism and little result 68. The Chinese-language US media outlet Chinese Radio Seattle reported that a dialogue on nuclear risks had been started, but central differences remained unresolved 69.

According to the OSINT aggregator Military Summary, which cites Politico, Trump subsequently joined a Berlin meeting of the Coalition of the Willing. He criticised there the allocation of billions in military aid to Kyiv and said that the Russian president was serious about peace 47. The German government information source deutschland.de reported that Chancellor Merz received the Coalition of the Willing on 19 November 2026 in Berlin 65. The Ukrainian state agency Ukrinform adds that Zelenskyy travelled to Berlin for the conference 66.

Arsenals and treaty framework

Regarding the arsenals, according to a report by the Bulletin of the Atomic Scientists cited by Reuters, China possessed approximately 410 nuclear warheads in 2023, the United States approximately 3.708. More recent estimates are higher: in its 2026 Yearbook, SIPRI puts China's arsenal at around 620 warheads, up from about 600 a year earlier, and the global inventory at 12,187 warheads, the vast majority of them held by Russia and the United States 58.

The Bulletin of the Atomic Scientists published an updated overview of China's nuclear weapons in 2025 59. The SIPRI Yearbook 2026 points to a stronger focus on nuclear weapons with increased escalation risks 58. For clarification, the Pentagon estimates according to the same sources that China will have more than 1,000 operational warheads by 2030. An independent confirmation of this figure from the reports available is lacking.

Regarding the treaty framework, several organisations reported on the situation. Arms Control Today reported in March 2026 that the United States pushed for a modernised treaty after New START expired on 5 February 2026 54. NTI described the transition from caps to impending risks 55. CEPA spoke of the beginning of the end 56. FIIA analysed the course of events 57. The Review Conference on the Treaty on the Non-Proliferation of Nuclear Weapons ended without consensus according to the UN press release of 26 May 2026 in view of increasing nuclear risks 60. ICAN reached the same conclusion 61.

As a secondary military development, the OSINT aggregator Our Wars Today reported citing Associated Press that two Russian nuclear-capable bombers left Vietnam on 19 November 2026 after landing in Da Nang, which was assessed as a sign of Moscow's military reach in Asia 51.

Indian media outlets (The Week, Hindustan Times, Rediff) also place the meeting in a foreign policy context and discuss possible consequences of trilateral nuclear talks for India 27 Hindustan Times10 THE WEEK. According to the aggregator report Dimsum Daily, the White House scheduled a press briefing after the summit 6. The aggregator NewsCord counted 44 comparable reports from international media for the announcement period. Radio Free Asia spoke on the evening of 19 November 2026 of a historic summit with nuclear arms control on the agenda 3132 Radio Free Asia.

Assessments and debates

The pro-Russian Telegram channel Intel Slava quotes China's Foreign Minister Wang Yi as saying that the meeting will go down in history. China wants to work together with Russia and the USA on the complete and effective implementation of the results and to establish an ordered multipolar world 19. There is no independent confirmation of the verbatim quotes from the available sources.

Between Yalta 2.0 and a thin declaration

The pro-Russian, state-aligned Telegram channel Readovka summarises international reception as the world standing on the threshold of a Yalta 2.0 and highlights approving Chinese voices such as Global Times and CGTN 28. The Kremlin-critical Moscow Times account on Telegram describes the outcome of the meeting instead with the title A New Yalta? In China, Putin Gets What He Wants, Mostly, thus more reservedly than a partial victory for Putin 30.

The Kremlin-critical channel Meduza Live concludes that a new Yalta conference did not take place, the final declaration is substantively thin, and describes China as the main winner 29. The OSINT aggregator Military Summary reproduces an analysis by Bloomberg columnist Marc Champion, according to which the meeting ushers in an era of the Big Three, ends the old liberal world system and marks Europe's final humiliation. Putin aims at ending the Ukraine conflict, Trump at controlling Iranian weapons and Xi at China's growing global role 46.

The OSINT aggregator War Monitor quotes Xi as saying that nuclear war cannot be won, must not be waged and everything possible must be done to prevent it 45. The OSINT aggregator Military Summary reports that Putin, Trump and Xi accepted a joint peace declaration that should strengthen global security, reform the United Nations, stabilise energy supply, prevent misuse by the International Criminal Court and reduce nuclear risks 33. The same channel refers to Trump being patched into the Berlin coalition meeting with criticism of billion-dollar aid to Kyiv and praise for Putin's willingness for peace 47.

The X account @OSINTdefender further reports that German Chancellor Friedrich Merz called on Trump before the summit not to take unexpected steps and to pay attention to the continued support of European allies and Ukraine 37. The X account @RKiesewetter quotes Finnish President Alexander Stubb appealing to Europe to respond to Moscow's attempt at a new Yalta with a new Helsinki 1975 and to speak with Putin itself. The post interprets this as adopting a framework set by the Kremlin 44.

The German news portal t-online rated the summit on 20 November 2026 as a fiasco 67, the German public broadcaster ZDFheute spoke of much symbolism and little result 68. The Chinese-language US medium Chinese Radio Seattle emphasised that dialogue on nuclear risks had started but central differences remained unresolved 69. The regime-critical Russian-language broadcaster Radio Svoboda published a preview on 18 November 2026 with expectations for the meeting 70. The Swiss business newspaper Bilan described on 18 November 2026 the competing agendas of the three heads of state 62. The OSINT aggregator Our Wars Today points out with reference to AP that Moscow demonstrated its military reach in Asia with nuclear-capable bombers in Vietnam parallel to the summit 51.

Think tanks on budgets, missile defence and Europe

The think tank CSIS describes the meeting on its X account neutrally as the first trilateral encounter of the three heads of state and announces ongoing analyses on the economic and security policy aims of the USA 2021 X: @CSIS50 X: @CSIS. The IISS points out in its X analysis that major nuclear expansion could fail due to budget constraints while missile defence would complicate the strategic balance 22. The Brookings Institution provided a preview of the competing agendas 52.

The Atlantic Council highlights with Fred Kempe that domestic and geopolitical constraints on the three heads of state could accelerate the collapse of the global order 4142 X: @AtlanticCouncil. Chatham House writes that the meeting gives many countries exactly a reason to act together 43. RUSI highlights with regard to Europe the first joint Franco-British nuclear air exercise Operation Rummy as a template for broader European nuclear cooperation 40. The disarmament-focused NGO ICAN rated the NPT Review Conference as a conference without a disarmament plan 61.

The OSINT aggregator Our Wars Today announced on 14 November, citing a report from the New York Post and an article from pravda.com.ua, that the meeting should address the preparation of an agreement to control nuclear weapons 27. This expectation only partially matches the later result, which provides for dialogue instead of an agreement 2369 Chinese Radio Seattle.

Symbolic weight and results

According to multiple sources, the meeting holds symbolic weight as the first three-way summit of the nuclear superpowers USA, Russia and China 25 Israel Defense20 X: @CSIS21 X: @CSIS32 Radio Free Asia38 X: @sentdefender50 X: @CSIS53 Radio Free Europe/Radio Liberty63 Forbes Ukraine64 Ukrainska Pravda68 ZDFheute. The signed declaration, according to the version published by the White House, is limited to general formulations, in particular on nuclear arms control, which is announced as dialogue rather than as a binding treaty 2329 Telegram: Meduza Live69 Chinese Radio Seattle. Multiple aggregators and German-language media report unanimously that the summit ended without a Ukraine agreement and without a new arms control treaty, although security, Iran and arms reduction were on the agenda 4849 Telegram: Our Wars, Today67 t-online68 ZDFheute.

The interaction between Trump's Reuters statement that negotiations are very difficult, the assessment by independent media that the declaration remains with formulaic compromises, and the IISS assessment that budget and missile defence questions limited the dynamic suggests that the summit will not be followed in the short term by substantial arms control agreements 2229 Telegram: Meduza Live68 ZDFheute. The expiry of New START without a successor regime 5455 Nuclear Threat Initiative56 CEPA57 FIIA and the failure of the NPT Review Conference 2026 without consensus 6061 ICAN additionally sharpen the political backdrop. At the same time, the European discussion about Operation Rummy and a joint French-British deterrence shows that the debate over extended deterrence in Europe continues, even though concrete steps are not substantiated in the available sources 40.

Possible developments include the continuation of announced dialogues on nuclear risks, further bilateral meetings where according to CSIS Trump and Xi have already met three times in 2026 21, a European debate about the role of French and British arsenals and the German position, as well as the political aftermath of Trump's involvement in the Berlin coalition meeting 4041 X: @AtlanticCouncil42 X: @AtlanticCouncil47 Telegram: Military Summary65 deutschland.de66 Ukrinform. Concrete statements about the so-called coalition of the willing beyond Trump's involvement and Zelenskyy's presence, about detailed positions of France and Great Britain or about intermediate-range negotiations are not substantiated in the available reports.

Sources analysed for this situation, by number of news items

214 news items from 107 sources
Web 69Telegram 28X 10RU 98EN 74UK 17DE 15FR 6ZH 4

This overview shows which sources the Monitor analysed for this situation. Being listed is neither an assessment nor an endorsement.

TelegramTelegram: Дмитрий Медведев RU 14

News items from this source (14) t.me

TelegramTelegram: Readovka RU 10

News items from this source (10) t.me

TelegramTelegram: Медуза — LIVE RU 10

News items from this source (10) t.me

TelegramTelegram: ТАСС RU 9

News items from this source (9) t.me

TelegramTelegram: Новая газета Европа RU 8

News items from this source (8) t.me

TelegramTelegram: Интерфакс RU 7
TelegramTelegram: The Bell RU 7
TelegramTelegram: Meduza in English RU 5
TelegramTelegram: Military Summary EN 5
XX: @CSIS EN 4
TelegramTelegram: Colonelcassad RU 4
TelegramTelegram: ВЕДОМОСТИ RU 4
XX: @RKiesewetter DE 4
TelegramTelegram: Our Wars, Today EN 4
TelegramTelegram: Defense Express UK 3
TelegramTelegram: Генеральний штаб ЗСУ UK 3
TelegramTelegram: Мир сегодня с "Юрий Подоляка" RU 3
XX: @sentdefender EN 3
TelegramTelegram: Санкции в РФ RU 3
TelegramTelegram: ✙DeepState✙🇺🇦 UK 3
TelegramTelegram: STERNENKO UK 2
XX: @IISS_org EN 2
TelegramTelegram: The Moscow Times (EN) RU 2
XX: @nicolange_ DE 2
TelegramTelegram: РБК. Новости. Главное RU 2
TelegramTelegram: OSINTdefender EN 2
XX: @CarloMasala1 DE 2
TelegramTelegram: War Monitor EN 2
WebRadio Svoboda RU 2
XX: @AtlanticCouncil EN 2
WebRediff EN 2
TelegramTelegram: bmpd RU 2
TelegramTelegram: InformNapalm UK 2
WebArms Control Today EN 2

News items from this source (2) www.armscontrol.org

TelegramTelegram: TASS NEWS 🇷🇺 🇩🇪 RU 1
WebDimsum Daily EN 1

News items from this source (1) news.google.com

WebTHE WEEK EN 1
Webssbulten.com.tr EN 1

News items from this source (1) news.google.com

WebOrganiser EN 1
WebEurasia Review EN 1

News items from this source (1) news.google.com

XX: @AFP EN 1
WebIl Mattino FR 1

News items from this source (1) news.google.com

Webt-online.de DE 1

News items from this source (1) www.t-online.de

WebTASS EN 1

News items from this source (1) tass.com

WebOnvista / dpa-AFX DE 1

News items from this source (1) www.onvista.de

WebLa Nouvelle Tribune FR 1

News items from this source (1) lanouvelletribune.info

WebSouth China Morning Post EN 1

News items from this source (1) www.scmp.com

WebWetterauer Zeitung DE 1

News items from this source (1) www.wetterauer-zeitung.de

XX: @ChathamHouse EN 1
TelegramTelegram: Intel Slava EN 1
WebIsrael Defense EN 1

News items from this source (1) news.google.com

WebRadio Free Asia EN 1

News items from this source (1) news.google.com

WebLife.ru RU 1
WebUA.NEWS RU 1
WebISNA News Agency EN 1

News items from this source (1) news.google.com

Webukrinform.net EN 1

News items from this source (1) www.ukrinform.net

Webdeutschland.de EN 1

News items from this source (1) www.deutschland.de

WebForbes Ukraine UK 1
WebUkrainska Pravda UK 1

News items from this source (1) www.pravda.com.ua

Webrferl.org EN 1

News items from this source (1) www.rferl.org

Web78.ru RU 1
WebZDFheute DE 1

News items from this source (1) www.zdfheute.de

WebChinese Radio Seattle ZH 1

News items from this source (1) chineseradioseattle.com

WebBundesregierung DE 1

News items from this source (1) www.bundesregierung.de

WebBusiness Insider (via Yahoo News) EN 1

News items from this source (1) www.yahoo.com

WebIPG-Journal (FES) DE 1

News items from this source (1) www.ipg-journal.de

WebPBS NewsHour EN 1

News items from this source (1) www.pbs.org

WebInternational Business Times EN 1

News items from this source (1) mx.ibtimes.com

WebNVIP (Новини Вінниці і Поділля) UK 1
WebThe Paper (澎湃新闻) ZH 1

News items from this source (1) www.thepaper.cn

WebVOA Chinese ZH 1

News items from this source (1) www.voachinese.com

WebRTS (Radio Télévision Suisse) FR 1

News items from this source (1) www.rts.ch

WebCarnegie Endowment for International Peace EN 1

News items from this source (1) carnegieendowment.org

WebThe Epoch Times EN 1

News items from this source (1) www.theepochtimes.com

WebCNN EN 1

News items from this source (1) edition.cnn.com

WebAl Jazeera EN 1

News items from this source (1) www.aljazeera.com

WebRossijskaja Gaseta RU 1
WebDiplomacy and Law EN 1

News items from this source (1) news.google.com

WebFondation pour la Recherche Stratégique FR 1
WebHindustan Times EN 1
Webbilan.ch FR 1

News items from this source (1) www.bilan.ch

WebNPR EN 1

News items from this source (1) www.npr.org

WebChosunbiz EN 1

News items from this source (1) news.google.com

Webbrookings.edu EN 1

News items from this source (1) www.brookings.edu

XX: @RUSI_org EN 1
WebAlwihda Info FR 1
Webسانا EN 1

News items from this source (1) news.google.com

Web茉莉花新闻网 ZH 1

News items from this source (1) news.google.com

WebNewsCord EN 1
WebModern Diplomacy EN 1
Websipri.org EN 1

News items from this source (1) www.sipri.org

WebCSIS EN 1

News items from this source (1) www.csis.org

WebSIPRI Yearbook 2026 EN 1

News items from this source (1) www.sipri.org

Webicanw.org EN 1

News items from this source (1) www.icanw.org

Webpress.un.org EN 1

News items from this source (1) press.un.org

WebDeutscher Bundestag DE 1

News items from this source (1) dserver.bundestag.de

WebUK House of Commons Library EN 1

News items from this source (1) researchbriefings.files.parliament.uk

Webarmscontrol.org EN 1

News items from this source (1) www.armscontrol.org

TelegramTelegram: Dmitry Medvedev RU 1
Webfiia.fi EN 1

News items from this source (1) fiia.fi

Webcepa.org EN 1

News items from this source (1) cepa.org

Webnti.org EN 1

News items from this source (1) www.nti.org

WebMinistère de l'Europe et des Affaires étrangères EN 1

News items from this source (1) www.diplomatie.gouv.fr

WebChatham House EN 1

News items from this source (1) www.chathamhouse.org

TelegramTelegram: Armed Forces of Ukraine - Збройні сили України . Telegram Channel by RTP [Army / Military / Navy / Air / україна] UK 1
Webthebulletin.org EN 1

News items from this source (1) thebulletin.org

WebArms Control Association EN 1

News items from this source (1) www.armscontrol.org

Cited sources

Footnotes from the report

Back to the overview